Subject: Liquid cooling from an historical perspective.
From: Paul
Date: 10/5/1999, 9:06 AM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
This is an excerpt from Herschel Smith's fine book
A History of Aircraft Piston Engines.
Published by Sunflower University Press, Manhattan Kansas.

Paul Lamar

"Drag and Air Resistance

The problem of frontal area received no real attention 
until 1917. For one thing, speeds were not so high that 
engine bulk mattered much. What misled designers for some 
time was the fact that Allied fighters were generally faster 
than German fighters despite the fact that all British and 
French pursuits used engines that were bulkier than the German 
inline types. When as nicely streamlined a plane as the 
Albatros was slower than the boxy S.E. 5, there seemed to be 
little reason for concern about frontal area: it does not 
seem to have been realized that the speed of the S.E. 5 was 
due to lighter weight and to the use of a flatter airfoil 
than the Germans employed [Fig. 1-2(a) and (b)]. Also, a 
short engine rather than a slim one was favored because 
shortness allowed weights to be concentrated in the interest 
of maneuverability. 

Two American engines of 1917 were the first to incorporate 
reduced frontal area among their design objectives. The best 
known of these was the government's Liberty, a big twelve 
whose two banks of cylinders were set at the narrow angle of 
45, instead of the usual 60 to minimize width. This effort 
was fairly successful. In most Liberty installations the 
height and width of the radiator matched those of the engine 
and the fuselage that resulted was narrow. Nevertheless there 
was just so much that could be done as long as cylinders of 
large bore and long stroke had to be used to obtain the 
desired power. The real possibilities of improvement lay in 
the direction of smaller displacement and higher speed, and 
this was the philosophy that lay behind the k-12, designed by 
Kirkham for the Curtiss firm. While the Liberty, running at 
1850 rpm, needed 1649 cu in. (27 L) to develop 400 hp, the 
k-12 got the same output from 1145 cu in. (18.76 L) by 
running at 2500 rpm.

In racing aircraft equipped with smooth "surface" radiators, 
the k-12 and its successors set numerous speed records. But 
in everyday use, the gains from reduced frontal area were 
largely negated by the continuing problem of radiator drag 
until the introduction of ethylene glycol (Prestone) in the 
late twenties allowed smaller radiators to be used. In Europe 
there was even a trend toward a very bulky kind of engine, 
called the "Wtype," with three banks of cylinders, and 
airplanes with these engines performed as well as any others. 

We had a special problem with radiator area in the United 
States since our summer weather is warmer than Europe's. 
European planes that performed well at home, notably the 
Fokker D-VII, overheated here. The performance of many 
American planes, forced to employ larger radiators, suffered 
by comparison with similar European craft. This led to an 
interesting result in North Africa during World War II. 
Spitfires and Messerschmitts used in desert heat had to be 
"tropicalized" with larger radiators, and performance fell 
off to the point where P-40s could fight Messerschmitts with 
some chance of survival, something they could never do in 
northern Europe. 

Prestone cooling might have led to complete displacement of 
the bulky radials in applications calling for high 
performance had not the Townend Ring and the NACA cowl come 
along at about the same time. The Townend Ring, a British 
invention, was a narrow cowling of airfoil section that was 
placed around radial engines. Often called a "drag ring" in 
the United States, it did not reduce frontal area but did 
confine the turbulence of the cooling air to the engine's 
diameter. It was also said to generate a forward thrust 
component from the expansion of the air as it was warmed in 
passing over the cylinders. Installed in an airplane whose 
fuselage was narrower than the engine's diameter, as was 
common before the era of cowled radials, it might add 10 to 
15 mph (16 to 24 km/hr) to the top speed. 

The American NACA cowl was named after NACA (the National 
Advisory Committee for Aeronautics), forerunner of NASA 
(the National Aeronautics and Space Administration) and the 
organization that gave the world most of its significant 
aerodynamic advances during the 1925 1940 period. It was a 
more sophisticated device than the Townend Ring, being longer 
and internally contoured to slightly pressurize the cooling 
air. Not as adaptable to existing aircraft as the Townend 
Ring because it required a bulkier fuselage to blend with its 
lines, it probably raised speeds by 20 to 25 mph (32 to 40 
km/hr) on suitable planes [Fig. 1-3(a) and (b )]. A 
beneficial side effect was that its confined airflow 
allowed internal baffling to be provided, leading to better 
cooling for two-row radial engines.

The final American development in cowls for radials came in 
1934 with the introduction of small adjustable flaps (which 
the British called "gills") at the rear to control the area 
of the cooling-air outlet. Besides further reducing drag, 
cowl flaps allowed the flow of cooling air to be restricted 
during cruising conditions, when less was needed. Previ- 
ously, without adjustable flow, an engine that was adequately 
cooled during takeoff and climb was overcooled during cruise. 
Water-cooled engines had never had this problem because 
radiator flaps for temperature control had been in use since 
before 1914. 

While American and British sophistication in cowl design 
seldom went beyond the provision of cowl flaps, the Germans 
and the Japanese took it a step further. By mounting a 
multibladed fan on either the propeller shaft or a 
faster-running shaft coaxial with it, such aircraft as the 
Focke-Wulf 190 and the Kawanishi 'Rex" were able to achieve 
the ultimate in low-drag cowling design for radial engines 
(Fig. 1-4). 

The Japanese may have been oversold on this idea, as some of 
their installations tended to overheat in the warmer combat 
zones, but at its best it was an admirable system. Today 
there is a good deal of evidence to suggest that engine bulk 
has been exaggerated as a handicap to high performance. 
Anything that has ever been done by a slim engine has 
ultimately been matched by a well-cowled bulky one. Indeed 
until recently the world's unlimited speed record was held by 
a radial-engined Grumman Bearcat. But high speed has always 
been somewhat easier to attain behind a slim engine; time and 
again, it has taken considerable time and work before radial- 
engined planes were able to match the performance of 
inline-engined craft. The final verdict is that speed can be 
had from a bulky engine but is easier to get from an engine 
with less frontal area."
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org