X-Mozilla-Keys:
Fred wrote:
I can't resist adding my two cents worth. I think conventional aircraft
engines are reliable, but marginal on lifetime for top end components. They
fail gracefully, slowly, but predictably, and cost money when they do.
I had a TR-182 for 19 years, ran it to 2000 hours before overhaul, but went
through three cylinders and two turbo overhauls as well as a lot of exhaust
system fixes in the period. And this is with an O-540 Lycoming putting out
235 horsepower at 31 inches of manifold pressure (that is, loafing). A
friend recently had to overhaul his Mooney (200 HP) at 1800 hours because the
exhaust valves were failing. Not worn. Failing. Chunks falling out.
I agree with that Fred. I average 500 hours on an exhaust valve
but I doubt seriously whether an auto engine would be any better.
That is one reason why I really really like the rotary. NO EXHAUST
VALVES!!!
You can lean it until it stops with no damage.
The maintenance literature suggests that longevity with current engines is
obtained only by running quite rich to keep things cool. In other words, one
needs to burn money to save money. Translation: the materials can't take the
temperature.
The situation worsens a lot when run with turbos. Top ends are limited to
little more than 1000 hours unless you stick to 65% power all the time, and
run rich. Run lean and pay the equivalent money in burned top ends
(expensive exhaust valves and the like). Temperatures are simply too high.
Liquid cooling (well done) can reduce these temperatures dramatically,
particularly around the exhaust port and seat. Lifetime problems thus
diminish.
I agree that one cannot pull an auto engine out of a car, drop it in and
airplane, and expect aircraft engine reliability. However, there is nothing
inherent in auto engine configurations that, given good materials of
construction and good design, should limit life compared to aircraft engines.
However, this takes money for good billet crankshafts, well configured heads
with generous cooling passages, etc.
Generally one finds that if the BMEP (proportional to manifold pressure) and
piston speed (in feet per minute) are in acceptable ranges (BMEP at about 150
psi or less, piston speed less than about 2500 feet per minute) one can get
excellent lifetime, small engines or large. By excellent I mean 10,000 hours
plus having been demonstrated in gas pipeline engines, and many high
performance diesels. So geared short stroke liquid cooled engines should
last as well as longer stroke direct drive air cooled engines turning lower
RPM, or longer (my expectation) due to better top end cooling. Pressures,
forces, stresses, and sliding speeds are all about the same.
Accessories, gearboxes, etc., are another story entirely. The devil is in the
details (as it is in engines). Bad accessories can ruin the record of a good
engine. And have in the past. True also with turbines.
Having expended my two cents, I remain,
Fred Moreno
There is another scenario going on here. Back in the good old
day's my mom's Packard had a great engine. From the look of the
inside of the engine 4340 forged everything. Now-a-day's everything
is cast this or powdered metal that. The car manufacturers are
much better at making an engine only expensive enough to do
the automotove job which is not all that hard compared to the
life of an aircraft engine.
You can change all that in some engines for the good stuff
but then you are up to the price of a real aircraft engine
without the light weight advantage.
In fact with computers they can take that one step further
and shut off the engine on you if you are asking more from
it than it was designed to give. An example is the 155 MPH
governed speed limit on European cars. A few years ago you
could drive flat out in Europe if the traffic allowed.
We were testing the new Corvette and a bunch of other sports cars
for Pop Sci and my wife Robin was pressed into service to drive
the Vette and convoy around Willow Springs race track for a photo
shoot. Robin rarely drives a stick and is not so aware of the need
to shift up. The Vette computer decided the engine had had enough
and just shut itself off. Now they may have changed the software
since that was a pre-production car.
Another drawback to any inline engine and that includes V engines
is the crank requires balance weights and the pistons and rods are
attempting to shove the crank out the bottom of the block.
This must be resisted of course. This adds weight. That is
not true for horizontal opposed engines.
The Orenda big block based Chevy V8
is an infamous example. Almost 50 million has been spent on
development so far, most of it Canadian tax payer's money and
most recently one was donated to the EAA museum by Lancair
along with the airplane it was installed in as Lancair found
it's power to weight ratio and cost (Remember that 50 million.
well somebody is going to have to pay it back) unacceptable.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org