Subject: Reliability / Life of Rotary vs Piston (SEAL Velocity)
From: Paul
Date: 10/10/1999, 9:40 AM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
Rodger Hilyard wrote:

Paul Lamar Wrote:

As I mentioned in a previous message the seal speed has
little to do with the life of a piston engine as ( almost
all the wear takes place when the seal is stopped at
the top of the stroke.) In that case the seal in a rotary
ought to last nearly forever as it never stops regardless
of the fact it is going 16% faster.


And that is why we find all the wear at the bottom of the
piston bore also.......

OK Rodger! Touche! There is little compression pressure
on the piston ring at the bottom of the piston engine bore. 
The Wankel apex seal is zipping along at high speeds with 
combustion pressure and you don't see wear like that. PL


 You once displayed a chart showing apex seal life vs
temp ( or vs oil mixture ).  Sliding apex seal equals friction
equals heat...the faster you slide it the more heat per unit time
you put in to it.
Getting the heat OUT  ( or not putting it in ) is the problem.
Ain't thermodynamics fun. : )
Rodger

The heat is not just from sliding. Consider the effect 
the 3000 degree combustion temp has with direct access to
the apex seal. A piston engine top ring has some protection
from the combustion temp by the upper land on the piston.

Never-the-less the wear on the apex seal and rotor housing
with two cycle oil mixed with the gas is minimal. If you believe
Francisco Iannette and Jim Mederer (Racing Beat) the wear  
is almost none existent with ceramic apex seals.
 
Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org