Subject: Vanc's talk at Copper State
From: Paul
Date: 10/10/1999, 9:21 AM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
Vance gave a very interesting talk at Copper State
on odd ball engines. Unfortunately he lumped the Wankel rotary
in with such stock scams as the Rand Cam 
http://www.regtech.com
and the Quasiturbine.
http://quasiturbine.promci.qc.ca

Vance should stick to engines that have been manufactered
in quantity and/or that have actually flown.

Vance claimed the World War I rotary radial was more balanced
than the Wankel rotary. Not true. A four rotor wankel is in
complete balance without the use of counter weights 
of any kind and in the WW I radial rotary (rr) the rods rock
back and forth and up and down. 

Vance also claimed the WW I
rr had a good power to weight 
ratio. Also not true as the engine Vance was most
fond of and used as an example was the Gnome Lambda 14 
cylinder two row rotary radial that weighed 396 pounds 
and put out only 160 HP. Perhaps by piston standards that
was good.  A Power Sport NA 13B rotary with gear box
puts out 210 HP and weighs 240 pounds with equavalent 
equipment. (No starter or alternator/generator)  

The big problem with a rotary radial and the show 
stopper was the aerodynamic drag of the cylinders 
whirling around in a circle. This started to sap HP
at about 1400 RPM. Not to mention all its other
problems.

Here is what Herschel Smith in his great book
A History of Aircraft Piston Engines concludes about the
WW I rotary radial.

" By 1918 the end was in sight for the  rotary [radial]. As long 
as most engines ran at 1400 rpm,  rotaries [radial] could have a 
useful role in combat; but by then there were reliable 
powerplants running at 2000, and the weight advantage of the 
rotaries [radial] had shrunk to insignificance. In addition, power 
had risen to levels that no rotary [radial] could hope to match. The 
fine water-cooled Salmson radials were demonstrating that 
the radial configuration to which the rotary owed its 
lightness was practical in a stationary engine, and British 
and Italian work with aluminum air-cooled cylinders had 
reached the point where it was clear that the whirling of a 
rotary [radial] was no longer necessary for cooling. The British, in 
fact, thought that they had, in the ABC (All British 
Corporation) Dragonfly, a stationary radial that was ready 
for production and service. There were to be no new [radial] rotaries 
after the big Bentley BR2. The future lay in the stationary 
types."

Vance also tried to convince everyone that the Wankel two rotor
was really equavalent to a 3.9 liter six cylinder piston engine.

I let him slide on this because if everybody believes it they
will be very impressed with a 3.9 liter engine that is
12.5 inches high, 12.5 inches wide, 18 inches long
and weighs only 197 pounds.

Some one has got to keep and eye on you Vance :-)
 
Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org