X-Mozilla-Keys:
Vance Jaqua wrote:
Yes the rods rocked, but not enough to require any
counterbalance for the single row - which you cannot
say for the Wankel - VJ
How would you balance the rods rocking Vance?
With a one rotor wankel rotary it is completely and totally balanced
with just two simple balance weights. A two rotor and the
balance weight mass are much reduced. A three rotor more
so. A four rotor and the balance weights disappear completely.
Vance also claimed the WW I
rr had a good power to weight
ratio. Also not true as the engine Vance was most
fond of and used as an example was the Gnome Lambda
14
cylinder two row rotary radial that weighed 396
pounds
and put out only 160 HP. Perhaps by piston standards
that
was good. A Power Sport NA 13B rotary with gear box
puts out 210 HP and weighs 240 pounds with
equavalent
equipment. (No starter or alternator/generator)
Comparing to engines produced in quanity for aircraft
a weight to power ratio of a bit over 2 lbs per HP is
very close to production certified engines and this is
after about 4 times as many years of development in
internal combustion history -that was less tha 10
years after the Wright brothers flew -
I will say that the pistons in a rotary radial, traveling
in a circle as they do, mass is so much less critical that they
can be made from higher temp cast iron or steel.
This is a seldom mentioned advantage of the rotary radial. PL
The big problem with a rotary radial and the show
stopper was the aerodynamic drag of the cylinders
whirling around in a circle. This started to sap HP
at about 1400 RPM. Not to mention all its other
problems.
That is certainly true - combined with the outrageous
gyroscopic forces - finding how to cool without
flailing the pistons through the air was probably the
key to being able to drop a very unhandy engine
config.
-VJ
Here is what Herschel Smith in his great book
A History of Aircraft Piston Engines concludes about
the WW I rotary radial.
" By 1918 the end was in sight for the rotary
[radial]. As long
as most engines ran at 1400 rpm, rotaries [radial]
could have a
useful role in combat; but by then there were
reliable
powerplants running at 2000, and the weight
advantage of the
rotaries [radial] had shrunk to insignificance. In
addition, power
had risen to levels that no rotary [radial] could
hope to match. The
fine water-cooled Salmson radials were demonstrating
that
the radial configuration to which the rotary owed
its
lightness was practical in a stationary engine, and
British
and Italian work with aluminum air-cooled cylinders
had
reached the point where it was clear that the
whirling of a
rotary [radial] was no longer necessary for cooling.
The British, in
fact, thought that they had, in the ABC (All British
Corporation) Dragonfly, a stationary radial that was
ready
for production and service. There were to be no new
[radial] rotaries
after the big Bentley BR2. The future lay in the
stationary
types."
Vance also tried to convince everyone that the
Wankel two rotor
was really equavalent to a 3.9 liter six cylinder
piston engine.
I still stoutly maintan that analysis of the processes
of handling and combustion and expansion of the
working fluid will show an almost perfect analogy to a six
cylinder engine of that swept volume operating at
2/3rds ecc. shaft speed ( one turn of the rotor taking
each of the 3 flanks through all four "strokes" ie
intake compression power exhaust- as you say it
matters only if you are trying to classify it for competition,
but I think it is also key in understanding the Wankel
operation - and I will probably never convert the
choir - Vance
I let him slide on this because if everybody
believes it they will be very impressed with a 3.9 liter
engine that is 12.5 inches high, 12.5 inches wide, 18 inches long
and weighs only 197 pounds.
I am! VJ
Some one has got to keep and eye on you Vance :-)
Paul Lamar
Some one with one eye on me and the other on you.
BTW Bill says you should stop spending all your time
on the net, and more on your installation in case
Continental decides they want their engine back and
he has to come to you for a Wankel :-) VJ
I am juggling the various aspects of my life as fast as I can :-).
Bill won't get an engine from me as I am not in the engine business.
Try Bruce Turrentine or Paul Yaw.
I finally figured out a way of showing that your reasoning is wrong
on this Vance. Yes, the rotor has three faces but there is only
one eccentric to remove power from the rotor. The rotor should
be considered a piston that rotates. For your arrangement to
be true each rotor face would need a separate eccentric.
Actully I think the wankel rotary is what it is. It is very subtle and
hard to totally comprehend. It has some very subtle structural
advantages
in its make up. I am still, to this day, having lived with it
for almost 30 years, finding out things about it that
amaze and please me. I don't think Felix Wankel would fully
comprehended what he had wrought if he were alive to this day.
A piston engine is like jerking a chunk
of aluminum back and fourth 6000 times a minute.
The inertial loads are enormous.
The crankshaft and rods are a stress analyst worst
nightmare. It is a total wonder they work at all.
I cannot see why people stick to them when something that is
so much better like the wankel rotary is available.
If 1/1000th of the R&D money was put into the wankel that
goes into the silly piston engine it would not be long before
piston engines would only be found in museums where
they belong.
Some day Vance you will see the light and be set free :-)
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org