Subject: Is the rotary designed for direct drive?
From: Paul
Date: 11/3/1999, 10:40 AM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
Bill Freeman wrote:

Perry Mick wrote:

I'm just curious if there are any other automotive direct-drive
conversions that have proven successful.  Volkswagon is the only
one I can think of. Do the bearings need to be changed in a VW
engine, or any other mods made to make it work?


Perry J. Mick
Mick Duckt N7XR
http://www.mickaircraft.com/duckt.htm



Perry,

I have built several VW conversions for some of the guys in
EAA Chapt 200, and have paid a lot of attention to them as
car and A?C engines, so here is what I know.

First, most VW conversions are direct drive and do not have
any extra bearings.  In addition (bad) they insist on taking the
 power off of the wrong end of the crank, primarily due to the
convienence of using the tranny attach pts on the case to connect
to an engine mount.

The only conversion that I am aware of that added an improved
bearing on the prop end was the Revmaster.  They bored and
stroked the poor old 1600cc motor to over 2500cc (2800 IIRC) and
well beyond sanity, IMHO.  They actually had to grind clearance
slots in the camshaft to clear the rods!  Revmaster added a long
prop bearing in place of the tiny outboard main in the stock VW.

The primary reasons this works are

   1) any VW that will last for any reasonable length of time is 65 hp or
       less

   2) prop extensions are rarely used

   3) Max rpms are ~3000-3200, most cruise at much less.  Out of balance
       and gyro loads increase as square of RPMs.

   4) props are VERY light, like 3-5 lbs (estimated).  I was quite
       surprised when I first handled a VW prop.  Vib/gyro loads are lower.

   5) VW is WAY overdesigned due to   
     A) no FEA when made
     B) had to run full throttle all day on autobahns

    crank is very strong, main bearings are *very* large for the hp,
    all the older cranks were forgings.


Bill

Another factor here Bill is Perry's prop is much smaller in diameter
than your average prop and the polar moment of inertia is much less 
as it is now very thin on the tips and made mostly from carbon fiber. 

The e-shaft is almost stright through with a lot of solid meat in the 
center due to the huge three inch diameter eccentric bearings. 
Also it is quite short at around 9 to 10 inches center of front main 
to center of rear main. 
Compared to just about any crank it is bullet proof. If there are any 
problems I suspect it is back by the flywheel end.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org