X-Mozilla-Keys:
Bill Freeman wrote:
Paul,
A few rough calcs leads me to believe that the adapter
alone is going to weigh 15 lbs or more! Add the
questionable access to the engine, poor out-of-plane
stiffness of the various plates, lack of an infinite fatigue
stress limit for aluminum, alum's low modulus of elasticity
(low inherent stiffness) and aluminum's low melting
pt (engine fire is not a nice thing to think about, but you
*must* retain the engine wt for a flyable airframe) and
this whole ideas seems pretty bad to me.
A whole new 4130 truss motor mount, using existing std firewall
attach points will be much lighter, stronger, fire resisteant, fatigue
resistant and stiffer (less vib problems) likely have better accy
access and probably cost less in the bargain since with the adapter
concept you have to buy a std motor mt and then build up this
structurally inefficient adaptor, too.
If the need arises to convert to a std AC motor later,
the interface point is the firewall, instead of the front of the
std motor mnt. There should be no problem installing a
std mtr mount at that point.
This sort of structure of bolted huge slabs of aluminum is
often seen in one-off PSRUs and is extremely heavy and
can be structurally very inefficient. I repeat, just because it
is made of aluminum does not mean that it is light. This sort
of structure is often simple to make but very structurally
inefficient due to much of the material being geometrically
poorly located to resist the loads.
A well thought out 4130 chrome-moly steel
truss structure (like the mount that you have designed) can
be much more efficient, and much lighter, even when made of
steel which is denser than aluminum.
Bill
Amen Bill! PL
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org