Subject: Mike Wills aluminum plate motor mount.
From: Paul
Date: 11/3/1999, 4:29 PM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
Bill Freeman wrote:

Paul,
A whole new 4130 truss motor mount, using existing  std firewall
attach points will be much lighter, stronger, fire resisteant, fatigue
resistant and stiffer (less vib  problems) likely have better accy
access and probably cost less in the bargain since with the adapter
concept you have to buy a std motor mt and then build up this
structurally inefficient adaptor, too.

Bill



Mike Wills wrote:
Bill,

  In an RV kit the motormount comes as part of the finish kit. The gearleg
sockets are integrated into the mount also. From the factory the gearlegs
are precision machined to fit each individual mount. The point is that I
already have the factory mount and gearlegs. If I cut it up and then later
decide to switch to Lyc power for whatever reason I have 2 choices. I can
either cut off the 13b structure and re-weld a structure compatible with
the Lyc, or I can replace the modified mount with a factory new mount and
gearlegs from Vans. The first choice sounds like a major pain in the butt
and the second is $1000.

  But as I said in a previous message I am becoming convinced that a
conventional welded truss is probably a better choice. The biggest hassle
is the space under the engine that I'm going to lose for radiators. I guess
I'll deal with that. Thanks for the input.

Mike Wills


Bill Freeman wrote:
Mike,
Thanks for the clarification.   I had no idea that the mount was so integrated,
and was assuming that there were mounting points on the firewall for the
truss structure, like most homebuilts and most factory jobs, too.  So much for
ASSUME.  ( ASS out of U and ME )  :-)

In that case, I still think that the truss-type subframe is likely to be
lighter and
safer overall than the thick-plate bolted aluminum system.

How about cutting the main eng mount tubes about 2" from the firewall (assuming
this leaves the gear mount OK, otherwise 2" fwd of the gear mount).
Slip a 3" long piece of the correct ID 4130 tube over the existing stub,
and bolt it in place with two AN4 bolts at 90 deg to each other.  Now insert
NEW pieces of 4130 into these sockets and bolt them into place, also with
two AN4 bolts.  Now bend, weld etc as req'd to mount the Mazda.   If you
need to revert, unbolt the NEW section of the mount, slip the old factory
part(s) that you cut off (and saved!) and drill thru the two existing 1/4"
holes (previously used for the new fwd mount) in the socket and bolt the
original mount back together.  Your reconnected mount will weight perhaps
1/2 lb more than stock and will be plenty strong enough.

But, if you don't want to do this . . .  and really NEED to make an adapter.
Apparently the primary problem is your lack of welding skills.  This may be
over blown.  If you can cut up the tubing, slot it for end attach brackets and
make the gussets, my guess is that you can find a local welder that will come
out and weld it all up for a reasonable fee.  Also, basic gas welding skills
are
not difficult to pick up, our EAA chapt has regular welding courses over the
last 20 yrs,  maybe a nearby chapter does this too.  Many JR colleges also
have welding courses.  Gas welding gear is <$250 and 4130 gas welds very
well and is structurally sound when gas welded.

Of course, it might not be so easy where you live, and I have not built
such an adapter, so can't be absolutely sure how hard it would be, but
 1/2" thick slabs of aluminum just don't turn me on much from a light,
strong and reliable aircraft structure point of view.

BTW. I'm a MSME, structural engineer, so I see this sort of stuff all the time.

Bill


The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org