Subject: mild steel vs 4130
From: Paul
Date: 11/15/1999, 6:02 AM
To: zz

X-Mozilla-Keys:                                                                                 
Gary Wolf wrote:

Joa,
   I read your posting that mentioned the crash of the mild steel plane and
it made me wonder why more mild isn't used, particularly in the cabin area.
I have rebuilt or constructed from new over 50 space frame chassis for
various vintage formula cars, all of them from England. None of them was
made from chrome moly. They were all made from cold-rolled mild steel welded
tube, mostly .050 wall, some .063, and were joined with nickel-bronze rod of
~90,000psi strength.

   Except for rusted out sections on Lotus Sevens (street car on salted
roads), I have never seen a broken tube or joint. The typical crash repair
is pretty extensive because the triangulated bulkheads stay intact as the
longerons fail in compression. The benefit is that the chassis is sacrificed
but the driver walks away intact. This sounds like what your friend
experienced. As the chassis collapses, the energy is dissipated over more
time and less is left to smack the pilot.

                                        Gary Wolf

I think it is a weight consideration. One probably can go down
on the wall thickness one or two steps useing 4130.
In other words where 0.063 mild would be called for in an aircraft,
the designer would use .049 or .035 4130. 

In race cars, where initial stiffeness
is everything, mild steel works fine as it has the same modulas
of elasticity as 4130 so there is no weight advantage in 4130 
for a given chassis stiffness. Also cost was a big consideration
in those early English space frame race cars. 

4130 will give a better buckling strength to weight ratio than mild
steel. Once you exceed that buckling strength however it might break
rather than merely collapse as the % elongation may not  be as 
high as salt-water-taffy like mild steel.

Never the less high strength steels are specified for roll over
structures in race cars to this day. If you are well straped
in you are better off in a high strength steel race car in 
a really severe crash using the same wall thickness tubing.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org