X-Mozilla-Keys:
Vance Jaqua wrote:
My engineering related two cents - The point for
"mild" steel is well taken - many structural sections
are chosen for weld limitations rather than max stress
- Piper used 1020 steel in a large portion of their
tube plane series. The trade is roughly 90ksi ult 4130
to60ksi ult 1020 and both are generally higher than
that due to cold working in the tube forming process.
the cost difference in seamless tubing is not great,
Though under rated welded tubing is much cheaper. Weld
cracking problems are more likely with 4130, and for
some reason the British practice of nickel-bronze
brazing never caught on in U.S. practice. If you can
heat treat the final assembly (not often done for size
and distortion reasons) the strength weight factor for
the higher alloys really starts to shine. A hard
lesson in over reaching with "high strength steels"
were the Grumman buses which frequently collapsed in
the middle of the sreet.
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org