X-Mozilla-Keys:
Letter to the editor of Sci American.
Copy to rotaryeng@earthlink.net
John Lynch wrote:
Dear Sir:
I was surprised and a bit dismayed to see your article about the Moller
Skycar (Dec. issue). I expect to see this kind of “hype-tech” in Popular
Science, but not in a magazine that purports to believe in the laws of
physics. If you take Moller’s published numbers and run even the
simplest engineering analysis, you will find that it’s not even remotely
possible that it will work as advertised. The most telling detail is
weight: Aircraft that actually work are light. Helicopters and their kin
are even lighter (relatively). The amount of stuff that he proposes to
haul around the sky is something like: 4 people x 170 lbs.= 680 lbs. + 8
engines x 135 pounds = 1080 lbs. + fuel: 960 hp x .50 lbs./hp/hr = 480
lbs./hr. x 3 hours = 1440 lbs. (to go the claimed 900 miles).
Opps! you are missing something right there John. This sounds a lot like
what I uploaded to the Internet or Genie a couple of years ago and I
missed this point too then! Paul Moller plans on throttling back to less
than 50% power in cruise so the fuel consumption goes down to
half or so.
The other factor is in theory given a 100% efficient
duct the thrust at a vertical speed of 10 fps 1000 HP or
550,000 lb ft/sec would be a thrust of 55,000 pounds. Since
the HP required to lift 2400 pounds at 10 FPS is only 24,000
lb ft/sec the ducts only have to be 44% efficient at 10 FPS.
The real question is: Can Paul Moller design a ducted fan that
is 44% efficient at generating near static thrust?
I think he can. Paul Moller is no dummy. He is just ahead
of his time.
Paul Lamar
Let’s see,
that adds up to 3200 pounds, and, Oh, I forgot to add anything for the
actual structure…. Well, that’s just a small detail. (Their website
claims a gross weight of 2400 lbs.)
This is where the half fuel weight comes into play John. PL
As a private pilot and experimental aircraft builder, who appreciates
the freedom to fly (and innovate) in this country, I’m concerned about
the kind of shaky development that Moller’s venture represents. It’s not
real aeronautical engineering, but it serves to consume public money
(NASA grants) and private funds (from gullible investors). In contrast,
when someone like Burt Rutan develops a new airplane (Varieze, Longeze,
Voyager to name a few), he usually flies it to Oshkosh for the big
fly-in and demonstrates it in front of thousands of people. We can at
least feel that we’ve seen it fly and know something of its real
capabilities. I’m VERY sure we won’t be seeing the Moller Skycar at
Oshkosh any time soon (unless they’re selling videos).
John Lynch
Santa Paula, CA
RV-4 N873SP
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org