Subject: Stock Ford C6 35 mmm output shaft.
From: Paul
Date: 12/21/1999, 5:25 AM

Bill Freeman wrote:

Paul,


I did want to comment on one statement you
made about the shaft diameter issue.  You stated ( I think)
that the stress was proportional to the diameter to the 4th
power.  Actually the section moment of inertia is proportional
to the diameter to the fourth, but because "c" in the

stress = (M * C)/ I         is equal to d/2, the final simplified

equation is      stress =   (128 * M )/ Pi * d^3

so the stress is actually proportional to the diameter to the
3rd power, but this is STILL a BIG deal, and I agree
 very strongly with your thesis that a 1.375 shaft is a BUNCH
weaker than a 2.25" shaft.  Esp when one is 4340 shot peened
and nitrided, and the other is heat treated 1050.

To be totally fair, you need to consider the fact that the
shaft is hollow in most AC engines, however this is a secondary
effect compared to diameter.  For example,

   2.25" diam shaft     I = (pi * d^4)/ 64   =  1.258 in^4

  2.25" OD x 1.5"ID  I=  (pi* (Dout^4 - Din^4))/64 = 1.0096 in^4

   the loss of section moment of inertia is about 20% for a huge
   hole in the shaft.  A 1.375OD shaft has

        1.375" OD >>     I = (pi * 1.375^4)/64 = 0.1755,

       so     solid, section MOI  ratio is 7.16;
             hollow,   sect MOI   ratio is 5.75


Bill

Thanks Bill for checking and correcting that. This newsletter works! 
 
Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org