Bill Freeman wrote:
BIG SNIP
BTW I think we have homed in on a problem with the PSRU shaft.
Seems the gust response of a home built airplane is a major
factor. Specifically the rate of pitch change numbers seem to vary
over a wide range. One radian per second comes up often. I suspect
it has a lot to do with the polar moment of inertia through a lateral
axis at the CG and the wing loading. Perhaps this is why the VW engine in
airplanes
had so much trouble with broken cranks. Low polar with low
wing loading?
Got any input on this? Got any numbers on common homebuilts for this kind
of polar moment of inertia?
Another question for you. Does the torsional response of a flywheel
shaft system vary with the rate of change of the forcing frequency
pulse or just the amplitude and frequency?
Paul Lamar
I'll take my laptop with my to Colorado and may find some time to do
some of this. As far as pitch rate, I would assume that the balance of
an aircraft MUST be in a narrow range at least for pitch.(CG, duh!) but
the total weight would be the variable to lower the polar moment of
inertia (like racecars). Since homebuilts are typically very light, this would
mean a lower polar moment of inertia, and less inertial damping.
[Scotty says "Cap'n Kirk, the inertial dampers are out! I can't hold'er much
longer!!, -- Sorry, I got carried away :-) ]
There can be very different overall **distributions** of the mass, with the
same CG, but since the people gas and engine are the primary masses and
are essentially the same in all AC (over a small range), they should not
vary a lot.
If you assume that the structure is roughly homogeneous on a per volume basis,
and that the major masses can be located pretty accurately from the wt and bal
chart for the AC, you should be able to make a pretty good estimate of the
polar moment of inertia for a few AC. The canards should be pretty good since
they have the engine at the rear and the people way up front to balance it. A
Cessna OTOH, has the people and gas under the wing, with the engine up front,
should have a lot lower polar moment of inertia, and HIGHER instantaneous
pitch response to gusts. Gayle gets *much* more motion sick in the C150 than
the Long EZ, and many have commented that the EZs ride better in turbulence,
not smoother, but "different". I always assumed it was that both "tail" and
wing
are lifting, and the bumps seem to be a double pitch sort of behavior with a
smoother
feel. May be the polar moment, also.
As to the rate of change of the force pulse affecting the response, my first
thought
is probably not. Assuming you mean the rate of change in the sense of the shift
in frequency, rather that the steepness of the pulse waveform. The pulse
waveform
may have some effect, but I have never really given this any thought. I'll
think
about it, but my guess is that the forcing frequency and the amplitude of it
are the
primary issues, of course the natural frequency of the system (shaft & prop)
is the
critical issue.
One additional point. My guess is that we can get away with a lot of
potentially
dangerous 'under-engineering' of prop shaft, bearing and flange systems when we
use these **VERY** light weight wood props. As soon as we put on a metal prop,
or even worse a variable pitch metal prop, my view is that you had better
have an
*extremely* stiff and strong (note that these are separate things, folks)
propshaft
system or you are going to have difficulties that might get you hurt. The
loads with
a 7 lb prop where 70% of the wt is within 6" of the hub is *very* different
from
a 50 lb prop with half the wt in the blades. Think about this before you
convince
yourself that you must have a variable pitch prop. The extremely light wt and
natural internal damping of wood props has probably saved many, many
homebuilders
from injury.
Take care.
Bill
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org