Subject: Shifting gears or constant speed props verse shifting gears.
From: Paul
Date: 2/7/2000, 9:02 AM

Rodger Hilyard wrote:

fixed pitch 70X78             const spd   var gear
   mph  rpm   bhp f lbs eff    f lbs eff  f lbs eff
    0   1940  108  407   0      603   0    525   0
   30   1950  109  393  28      530  26    505  25
   60   1960  110  353  51      480  50    460  47
   90   2080  118  327  66      425  63    420  62
  120   2400  130  307  76      366  73    365  73
  160   2500  149  283  81      299  80    299  80
  190   2720  160  268  83      268  83    268  83

Yada, Yada, Yada......

 Paul you obscure the point.

   The point being, that a variable speed reduction unit could
provide a performance increase for short field and obstacle
clearance and be more COST and WEIGHT efficient than;
     (1) a reduction unit plus a variable pitch prop and
     (2)  much better than a reduction unit plus fixed pitch prop alone.

 Rodger

Not really :-) It has taken me this long just to get Vance
to agree on the same definition of prop efficiency and  fixing
Vance's chart for the constant speed prop. I would not say shifting gears 
or the infinitely variable gear box is much
better. It certainly would not have a cost or weight advantage.

If you choose an automobile transmission of some sort it is going to be really
big and heavy to take a continuous 150 HP. We are now only using a very small
part of the Ford C6 auto transmission. We are only using one set of gears
out of the two that are in there and none of the other very heavy parts
such as the torque converter. The output shaft would still have to 
be increased in size and bearings added to take the prop gyro bending
and thrust loads. Automobile transmissions are not designed for those
loads.

Where are you going to get a infinitely variable gear box?

BTW This is Vance's chart, not mine. 

I will let what I said last night sink in with Vance and I will then
go after the infinitely variable gear box :-) Patience!

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org