Russell Kent wrote:
Charlie Kuss wrote:
Russell,
I am leery of all this over complication to the fuel system. Every item added to the system
adds another point of failure.
I understand and agree to a point. The component *most* likely to fail is the pilot. Let's
try not to depend overly much on that one. If you depend on the pilot to run a transfer pump
periodically, or switch a tank selector valve, or whatever, then one day he won't. Tracy did
it and ended up pumping an unknown quantity of fuel overboard. My proposal has 3 components
not absolutely required to run the engine: an additional pressure regulator, a transfer pump,
and a cross connect valve. Neither the transfer pump nor the cross connect valve are used in
"normal" operation, so their failure rates are less of a concern. That means that the
"incremental risk" over a "only-what's-required" design is the failure rate of the additional
pressure regulator. And even when that pressure regulator does fail, you still haven't lost
the whole engine.
If an item fails on your system, the other side of the system is of little use, IF the fuel
tank on that side is empty or near empty. This will reduce the effective SAFE range of the
ship.
I don't agree. The assumption is that both sides of the system start with the same quantity
of fuel and both sides are consumed at the same rate. If one side is empty, the other side is
likely empty or very close. If the one side is *not* empty, then the pilot has time to engage
either (or both) the transfer pump and the cross connect valve. Those devices exist in my
idea in order to help the pilot cope with other failures in the system.
That said, I would like to suggest that you can improve your idea by NOT separating the fuel
rails by rotor. The 13B has 2 fuel injectors per rotor. A safer method would be to feed BOTH
primary injectors off of one fuel rail and the secondaries off of the other rail. A failure
with this setup would result in a loss of power of less than 50% and would allow much
smoother operation in the "limp home" mode.
Hadn't thought about that. Better still would be to plumb primary injector #1 and secondary
injector #2 to the left rail, and primary #2 and secondary #1 to the right rail. That way you
have equal consumption and minimum power loss (presuming losing a primary injector causes a
more noticeable power loss than losing a secondary injector).
Russell Kent
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org