Charlie and Tupper England wrote:
Gary Casey wrote:
I have been following the "great propeller debate" and I think I
understand the chart. What it's saying, if I'm not mistaken, is that the
twist in a constant speed prop cannot be optimum at all pitch angles and
this is why the fixed pitch prop is slightly more efficient at many
operating points. What seems to be a bit excessive is the static thrust
difference of almost 50% between the fixed and variable pitch props.
Your chart shows that the engine is producing 311 ft-lbs of torque at
2700 rpm, but only 292 ft-lbs at 1940 rpm. I would have thought that
with an engine of the "aircraft type" with a mild cam and fixed spark
advance that the torque at 2000 rpm would be higher than at 2700 rpm. Is
your data from actual engine tests?
It sounds like you are using automotive logic on a/c engines, & it
doesn't really apply. Car engines have a torque peak at X rpm and a HP
peak at X + Y rpm. A/c engines are not rated at the peak HP they are
capable of, even in stock form. That's why it doesn't really mean much
when you say they are tough enough to handle 75% power all day long.
'75%' is probably closer to 40% of what the engine can actually make in
peak HP. Paul, do you happen to have some torque curves for a/c engines
in that extensive library of yours? I'll bet the torque peak is fairly
close to the rpm where the engine is rated for max power.
I don't have torque curves but the HP is going straight up at the red line
RPM.(about 2600) Many AC racers run their AC engines at 3500 RPM and get a
proportional
increase in HP. AC engines breath very well at 2600 RPM. It is one of the reasons
the BSFC is better than your average car engine. The crank, valves and rods are
designed
to last 2000 hours at 2400-2700 WOT but if you run your AC engine at 3500 RPM
all TBO bets are off.
I think that this is almost always overlooked when comparing a/c to auto
conversions. This is only my opinion, but I'll bet that if you push an
a/c engine to its TRUE peak output on a dyno, then select an auto engine
capable of that power & operate it at the 'rated' power levels of the
a/c engine in the same environment, the basic core engine would be AT
LEAST as reliable as the a/c engine. This does NOT say that all the
systems surronding the conversion will be as reliable as the a/c engine.
I aquired an extensive collection of a/c magazines going back to the
early 70's with a homebuilt purchase. Reading about a/c engine failures
in homebuilts from several decades ago is very enlightening. In the days
before complete kits with tested fuel & cooling systems, the crop of
engine failures looks very similar to the current auto conversion
failures. Most of the time it was a system failure downing the plane, or
a system failure causing the engine failure (as in cooling problems
causing engine seizure). These failures were with certified a/c engines.
That said, I do think the rotary is the best solution for a better a/c
engine. This post is to say that if you want the right answers you've
got to ask the right questions.
Charlie
I guess I said what Charlie said here :-)
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org