Subject: Big rotaries top secret, also aviation.
From: Paul
Date: 2/14/2000, 12:33 PM

Bill Freeman wrote:



The JD 580 Series SCORE engine was 5.8 liters per rotor, peripheral intake
and exhaust ports, 8.5:1 compression ratio, direct injected spark assisted
stratified charge. Rated speed was 3600 rpm, although some tests were run to
about 4200 I think. The basic engine has been run to about 650 hp per rotor,
and a five rotor engine has been built and tested. Deere made a lot of
marketing claims before having the test data to back them up. An eight rotor
engine "might" be theoretically doable, but based on experience I think that
six is probably the real limit, and not a very practical one at that. Many
engines were run at the 375 hp per rotor rating, and many at a 500 hp per
rotor rating. It was later that the 650 hp rating was acheived, and I don't
recall a lot of the details. I was working on a smaller engine at the time
(although I worked almost exclusively on the 580 from 1985 through 1991). The
engines produce the power and fuel economy that is shown, although there are
still a handful of performance and durability issues to address. The 580
Series engine is definitely NOT in any currently funded US military program,
although there are a few unfunded programs for which the engine might make
sense.

Regarding the Deere aviation engines -- two engines were in work. The 70
Series and the 170 series. The 70 Series had a lot of NASA funding (and a
spin-off had Air Force funding but for a land based genset). I don't recall
the target ratings, but the engine was used for a lot of exotic proof of
concept work, including titanium rotors, combustion development, electronic
unit injectors, multi-stage turbocharging for high altitudes, high speed
operation, high BMEP operation, etc. The PSRU shown in the picture was not
real. Only a wooden mock-up was ever made. The engine was only run in
stratified charge form -- never gasoline homogeneous charge. Many different
configurations were run.

The 170 was a joint venture with AVCO-Lycoming and was to produce I think
around 500 hp out of 3.4 liters (for a two rotor engine). Also stratified
charge only. Two engines were produced. The first one failed for reasons I
don't recall (but not very significant problems I don't think). The second
engine ran quite well as I remember, but AVCO terminated the JV due to the
extreme downturn in the GA market (around 1987 or so?).

All JD SCORE engines were turbocharged, direct injected, spark assisted
stratified charge engines using two stage injection -- pilot and main
injectors for each rotor. Most used peripheral intake ports. Those that used
side ports were lackluster performers, and I believe that peripheral ports
would have been used for all new applications. All used aluminum end housings
with flame sprayed moly coatings. The coatings were problematic. Getting
adequate strength in the aluminum housing hub area was also a problem (don't
forget that turbo stratified charge combustion pressures can exceed 1200psi
easily). Rotors were cast nodular iron except in high output engines where
investment cast stainless steel was sometimes used. In the 580 series, rotor
cracking was a problem with the 120 pound iron rotors. Ceramic seals were
used in the high output 580 engines, although less costly materials worked
well in the smaller engines. Rotor housing coatings were detonation gun or
HVOF tungsten carbide or chrome carbide.

Anyone say "expensive?"

Jon Lauter
Rotary Power Marine Corporation
www.rotarymarine.com

Thanks for the info, Jon.  Always wondered why they never were
used in any real systems.  What do you think was the real barrier
to actual production?  Fuel burn (BSFC)?  Just too new an idea?
Actual problems with making them work at the desired power
levels?  Cost?  Really curious -- somebody for some reason said
"no" to production and "yes" to a conventional piston engine.
Why??

Bill


The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org