Subject: Hybrid cars
From: Paul
Date: 2/18/2000, 7:01 AM


charles harbert wrote:

Paul, I think you will see a lot of these type of cars in the very near
future
because they are so efficient. By hybrid, I'm referring to combination
electric/IC engines. These cars get 50+ mpg, and are virtually non-polluting,
zero emission vehicles. These highly efficient cars are now possible
because of
new computer control systems that smoothly start and stop the IC engine that
supplements the battery system.

If the hybrid gets 50 mpg, I can make the same prime mover produce 80 or 90
mpg without all the extra hybrid components. Guarenteed.
Hybrids are NOT efficient.  The multiple transformations of the power cause
LARGE net losses.   The most efficient drivetrain is a prime mover directly
driving the wheels.   The substantial extra weight of the batteries, motor,
generator and control electronics guarantees a MUCH worse overall
thermal efficiency.   I have spent *years*, literally, designing, modeling,
building
and testing hybrid vehicles (25 yrs ago) and they are a guarenteed dead end
without stupid laws mandating a particular technology.

Several existing Honda "normal" cars meet the 'ultra low emissions'
qualifications,
and I believe that I have read reports that their exhaust is cleaner than the
ambient air in some cities.  We are nowhere near done making clean cars that
are reasonably affordable and reasonable simple, at least compared to hybrids.


If gas prices would get to a level that encouraged conservation, these cars
would pay for themselves in a very short period if you have a commute.
Perhaps a
new, more efficient, side port rotary engine could be adapted to work in
one of
these type of cars. The rotary advantages of small size and weight with
high hp,
could make a lot of sense.

   So you want to give tons MORE of your money to the OPEC billionaires so
you can have the opportunity to trade in your airplane and car for a crappy
little
expensive, slow, contankerous piece of junk which costs 2- 6 times what your
current car costs??   An actual shortage of fossil fuels WILL cause ACTUAL
price increases, **someday**.   Until then, I strenuously object to central
planners
who are smarter than everyone else (can you say communism?) deciding what
is best for us.  It does not work.  This has been proven time and time
again, and
if you continue to believe the BS propaganda put out by the radical
environmentalists you will be selling your freedom pretty short.

I have studied solar engineering in college, built many solar devices and have
a totally solar electric cabin in the mountains of Colorado.  I embrace this
technology where it makes sense and reject it where there are more affordable
options.  Price measures the value of things and permits absolutely valid
comparison
of competing alternative technologies.  Currently, fossil fuels are in great
supply,
plus there are trillions of tons of natural gas under the continental
shelves in the
form of methane hydrate (metastable ice-methane solid).  Check it out on the
web.  The days of a REAL shortage of conventional fuels is likely beyond the
lifetimes of all alive today.  When we DO need to go to unconventional designs,
it will probably be fuel cells burning either hydrogen (if the storage tech
improves)
or methanol catalyzed to free up hydrogen.  Solar power can electrolyze water to
make the hydrogen, with water as the exhaust.  This can be a closed cycle.
But let these things develop naturally as they make economic sense.  Private
A/C will probably be a thing of the past.

My friend Don Sherman does not agree.

Don wrote:
hybrids are merely an intermediate step--like battery-powered electrics. No
one can afford dual drivelines and all the extra complexity. As I said, zero
emissions will be the law of YOUR land and hybrids don't qualify. DS

   Don is right.  Looks like the CA crazies are going to really muck up the
car market.   When you folks gonna wake up and eject those jerks?


I am definitely not in favor of raising gas prices artificially by taxes or
any other means. The current run up in prices will not last. There is no
world wide shortage.

The cost of these hybrid cars will be subsidized in CA by tax money and I will
vote against the SOB's that passed it into law. I hate legislated invention.
Hybrids would never make it on their own in the marketplace. Too expensive
and too heavy.

Paul Lamar

    Go get 'em, Paul.

 Let's continue to believe in FACTS, SCIENCE & FREEDOM to choose for
ourselves.

Bill

This is the answer to congestion and pollution.

Paul Lamar

The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org

devFOES.GIF