I have a C177RG as my present mode of air transportation. Here is a review of
the new "drop down emergency wind driven alternator" that I advocated this
fellow adopt for his long flights into Mexico. It is STCd for 210s, he is
getting it STCd for C177s (put it in on a 337 form). In any case, where it
comes to power we all seem to have many alternatives besides batteries.
Here is our ongoing discussion of this subject-
Bill, another option might be to consider the soon-to-be-
certified standalone backup alternator that GAMI is offering; mount that in
PLACE of the vacuum pump, and run the AI and DG from electricity, primarily
from the new alternator, with the old electric system as a backup?
Marc wrote:
There has been a long running advertisement in CPA for a
wind driven alt that drops from on of the large access panels in the 210
wing. When I called the guy, he said the Cardinal would be identical
(appears to have the same access panels). The power at 12 v would depend on
airspeed, but probably enough for an electric dg!
Larry wrote-
I just finished installing this backup turbine alternator that Marc
discussed (and I discussed a few months ago when I purchased it - just now
getting to the installation). It is called a BAS-28 Turbo Alternator.
The installation turned out NOT to be just like what it is for the C210.On
the C210, it is installed under the right wing access panel just outside the
copilot's door (in fact, it must first be retracted from outside before the
copilot's door can be opened). This is in the same relative position where
the under wing loading light is on the Cardinal. I elected to install it
under the access panel aft and just outside the right rear passenger window.
The existing access panel is too small, so we had to cut the backing plate
out and cut the hole larger. This was fairly easy, and the kit includes a new
backing plate and cover of the correct size that is riveted in place. The
other mounting dimensions were similar to the instructions for the C210
series. The internal frame of the unit is mounted between existing inner and
outer in wing bulkheads. A cable release to deploy the alternator down from
inside the wing is mounted through the headliner just forward of the wing
carry through spar on the right side. This only took a small modification to
the supplied bracket. The unit is wired over the door and down to the
electrical bus. It has its own circuit breaker built in to the panel at the
release cable, and it is self regulated.
I flew it for the first time yesterday. As per the supplier's instructions,
I turned off the main alternator switch first (to simulate an alternator
failure and while leaving primary avionics and beacons on). After deploying
the unit by pulling the release cable, the unit drops into the wind stream
and immediately starts providing power. My amp meter went from a discharge
to a center position. After about a minute, I even noted a small charge
indication. I turned on landing lights to increase the load with an expected
slight discharge, but nothing as much as it would be on battery power alone.
So far, the unit seems worthy. A ground test with a garden leaf blower
indicated just over 14 volts on a
voltmeter ) before hooking up the output feed to the aircraft's bus. The
manufacturer says that it should put out 30 amps at 130 KIAS. I couldn't
gauge the actual amperage in flight, but it more than took care of all the
normal loads. I am just finishing up the FAA form 337 paperwork (with any
luck it will be signed off today). I am working with the manufacturer and
will prepare for him some drawings so that he can pursue a serial STC for
the Cardinal. I plan to be at Boyne Mtn. if anyone wants to have a look at
it. Oh, it weighs about 6.5 lbs. and I believe he is selling them for about
$1,600.
I just purchased the B.A.S. turbo alternator from
Basic Aircraft that was designed for the C210 (they
advertise in several mags including in CPA). It will be
mounted in the wing on the co-pilot's side in the rear
inspection plate opening. When not in use, it is fully
recessed and flush with the bottom of the wing. If needed, a
cable release is pulled from just aft of the copilot's head
and forward of the wing spar. The wind driven alternator
drops into a position facing the airstream. They tell me
that with 130 KIAS, the unit puts out 15 amps of continuous
power that is wired directly into the main bus via a switch.
I haven't installed it yet. I'm flying into mainland Mexico
this Friday with Liga International ("Flying Doctors"). It
is scheduled for installation as soon as I get back. Since I
am the prototype Cardinal, they sold it to me for $1,000.00
with the understanding that my IA complete drawings and get
FAA inspection for a field approval so that they can follow
up in getting a serial STC. I believe that the normal price
is around $1,800. I mention this thinking that this backup
system may meet Braly's requirement for standby power. It
wouldn't produce the power of a second alternator, but it
should produce enough amperage to power his ignition system.<
His follow up using it under actual conditions:
Subject: Alternator Replacement
I returned from another of my monthly flights to Sinaloa Mexico Sunday late
afternoon. The bad news is that I lost my alternator about 80 miles south
of the border while southbound on Friday. The good news is that the under
wing BAS Turbo Alternator not only functioned well, but it allowed me to
complete the trip down and the return home.
During about 13 hours of use, it completely kept up with my normal day time
electrical load (included transponder, GX60 GPS, Strikefinder, intercom,
E.I. fuel flow computer, E.I. engine scanner, all factory gauges, and even
my Sony CD player.) It proved itself, as advertised, as a continuous duty
unit, not merely for short time emergency use only. I operated the landing
gear and flaps normally, but there was an ammeter discharge during their
operation. At cruise airspeed, the BAS unit did always bring the battery
charge back up to full even after these discharges over time (i.e., there
is a charge trickle even over carrying the normal daytime use electrical
load). I turned on landing lights and strobes in addition to the normal
load momentarily. This resulted in a needle width discharge. I wouldn't
have been as confident continuing the flight at night or in IMC, but it
would have been doable. It would only have required reducing unnecessary
load in order to operate the strobes and pitot heat without a discharge.
During approach and initial climb airspeeds, there is not enough fan RPM to
supply the whole demand, but, otherwise, it proved to be an excellent
addition to the plane.
(This week my mechanic will be sending his installation modification
drawings to the manufacturer so that he can pursue the serial STC for the
Cardinals. I have no financial interest in the product.)
My question to the group is concerning the replacement or rebuild of the
primary alternator. I queried National AirParts about their 70 amp
alternator. They said it is fully compatible with my presently installed
Zefftronics overvoltage protected regulator (in fact they said that
Zefftronics participated with them in the development of their high output
alternators.) They said that their unit is a 105 amp unit that is derated
to 70 amps. They have a PMA, and their unit is a direct replacement for the
stock unit without mounting or wiring modification (he did say that a peak
surge may pop the 55 amp alternator circuit breaker, but that this would be
unlikely.) They want $662.40 for the unit (after giving a 10% discount for
AOPA affiliation.) Parenthetically, their 100 amp unit requires an upgrade
to minimum 6 gauge wiring from the field and a larger circuit breaker. I
did not ask about that unit's pricing.
Since I already have the under wing BAS TurboAlternator backup, my mechanic
suggests not spending the money for the above replacement. He says that a
rebuild of mine shouldn't cost more than about $150. The technician at
National AirParts countered this by claiming that usual alternator rebuilds
only include replacement of bushings/bearings, new brushes, and a bench
test. He says this usually results in very low life.
Marc