Subject: EFI Display [long]
From: Paul
Date: 3/19/2000, 7:42 AM

Barry Gardner wrote:

Paul,

Is it too late to vote on the display question? I was travelling
last week and am just catching up on my mail.

I agree with many of the people posting that there are a lot of
parameters pilots are interested in monitoring. We could all make
lists that eventually would correspond to the fanciest panel any
of us has ever seen. But composing the union set of all lists
fails to address a couple issues that also seem important to me.

Other issues would warrant keeping a multi-sensor device somewhat
more simple rather than more complex.

First of all, when monitoring an engine, I want to monitor
several things nearly simultaneously. RPM, manifold pressure,
EGT, for example, might be things I want to watch together. If an
engine is running roughly, I'll want to simultaneously watch fuel
pressure, RPM, and voltage to try to diagnose whether I have a
fuel or an electrical problem. There are a lot of examples we
could make up.

Making these indicators share a display means that either I have
to wait for the display to cycle or I have to manually push
through the various menus. And "simultaneous" to me means NOW
rather than wait for 10 or even 5 seconds. If I have engine
trouble, I'll be in real hurry for data upon which to base my
troubleshooting.

Some gauges I'll want to know nearly all the time and will
combine them with others to draw conclusions. I can't imagine not
wanting to know RPM while watching other parameters. I can't
imagine not wanting to watch voltage. YMMMV. But to me, that
means that a separate gauge is preferred to reading that data off
a multi-function display.

The implication of that is that more gauges are preferred to
fewer gauges because they allow one's mind to process
simultaneous data. That is, of course, why the proposed display
has four lines of simultaneous data. But just because one CAN
make the multi-function display combine data doesn't lead to the
natural conclusion that it SHOULD.

Secondly, while it is true that digital devices can be programmed
to process and interpret data from different sources (volts and
amps in wide ranges), cost considerations may make it nearly as
economical to buy off-the-shelf alternatives. If one has to buy
the sensor anyhow--true for water pressure, water temp, etc,
etc--one finds that the actual gauge from the automotive
aftermarket is nearly free. Or if one looks at Perry Mick's
salvaged RX7 dash, the automotive version IS free unless one is
too lazy to cut it into the panel.

My point is that making the four-line display programming more
complicated or suggesting a display with even more lines of data
drives cost of the multi-function device UP when there are other
economical off-the-shelf alternatives easily available. The
economy of a multi-function device for some jobs is small or
non-existent.

Thirdly, while all of us know that we often have long periods in
flying when we have plenty of time to fiddle with displays, there
are also time periods when we must have our eyes outside the
cockpit. The spate of recent GA mid-airs is a great reminder of
this. Some people have even talked about moving transponders to
the top of one's panel so that one could set the code without
putting one's head down. Given that thinking, the notion that I
would want to combine as many parameters onto a display that I
have to either program or cycle through manually seems
wrong-headed. It adds to pilot workload when most people are
re-emphasizing "see-and-avoid" approaches to collision avoidance.

I think that multi-function devices are great. But I want
information that tells me what the engine is doing that isn't
easily available any other way.

There are only two factors that increase my desire to pile up
functions on that four-line display. One is cost--everyone knows
that the gizmo can interpret data from a wide variety of sensors
with nearly only a change in programming. It can track RPM, tell
time, be an elapsed time counter (up or down), and probably start
your 12V coffee pot if you want. But are those things you really
want to make it do?

The other factor in favor of multi-function displays is economy
in panel space. Everyone is concerned about that but it's
important not to go overboard, at the cost of some of the other
factors above.

The best analytical analogy for wrestling with this question is
the Shopsmith saw, the Swiss Army knife or the Leatherman tool.
If I crash in a jungle somewhere, I'll pull out my Super
Leatherman from my flight bag and it will be worth its weight in
gold. But for common use in everyday repairs, it's not the first
tool I pull out. If you've ever had to switch from one tool to
the next, you know that multi-purpose tools come with a price.
They aren't usually the best at anything really and they can be
pain to switch from function to function. If multi-function tools
were always best, we'd all have Shopsmiths.

Don't get me wrong; I love gizmos. Between the factory gauges and
various aftermarket stuff, my turbo RX7 car measures RPM,
groundspeed, aftermarket vacuum/boost gauge (i.e. manifold
pressure), Hobbs time, ammeter, system voltage, voltage back at
the fuel pump (it's different because of the step-down resistor),
fuel pressure, EGT, fuel-air mixture, oil pressure, oil temp, and
water temp. But I'm not as enthusiastic about putting all that
data onto a four-line display that I have to scroll through or
program in flight.

If I've got troubles, I'm going to be BUSY. And THAT's when I
need that data.

My $.02.

Barry Gardner
Wheaton, IL

The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org