Barry Gardner wrote:
You wrote: "Actual gross weight was then automatically taken into
consideration.
An angle of attack indicator will not give you that info."
Tsk, tsk, Paul! A wing will stall at the same angle of attack, no
matter what speed or weight, with the stall speed dependant only
upon the type of airfoil being used. Look at a graph of wing
section lift coefficients; you'll find that the only two
variables are amount of lift generated and the angle of attack.
No footnotes, no family of other graphs that take weight or speed
into account. Just angle of attack (AOA).
When an airplane is heavily weighted, the wing has to fly at a
greater angle of attack to generate the lift necessary.
Your friend's method of stalling at altitude and then recording
the number will take the weight into account. Though the density
altitude will be different up high, the INDICATED airspeed will
be the same because the error will be the same one measured by
the pitot-static system. It's a good bootstrap substitute. But an
angle of attack indicator is the One True Religion on this topic.
It's the reason that Navy pilots put those planes on carriers
using AOA meters. They've got to squeek that baby on that dinky
mobile landing strip with a minimum of error. They might have a
full bomb load or an empty one; they might have a lot of fuel
remaining or be flying on vapors. They use AOA as the one and
only consistent reliable way to hit the minimum speed at a given
weight.
Where's that guy with the screen name HornetBall? He sounds like
someone with experience using AOA. I'm just a lowly Cessna
driver. No AOA in my 172M, to my regret.
Barry Gardner
Wheaton, IL
Yes Barry you are right. Sorry I did not receive and read this before I uploaded
that last message. Would have saved me that clarification.
The info I was referring to was the stall airspeed and gross weight.
Here is another interesting story. Dick Rutan checked the fuel load of
the Voyager over Africa by measuring the stall speed. He doubted the
fuel gages and fuel consumption log. Obviously air density was estimated
by outside air temp and altitude.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org