Bill Freeman wrote:
SNIP
I was able to break the cast iron seal easily while prying it
up from the slot. It occurred to me the way to make better apex
seals is make them out of 4130 and heat treat them so they are
tough and hard to fracture with detonation. Then use a
D-gun to coat them with tungsten carbide on the top wear surface.
You can clamp a bunch together when coating them to cut the cost.
They then must be ground and polished to get the nice radii on
the top.
Also nitriding the top of a heat treated 4130 seal might also
work and that would be a LOT cheaper.
I just don't think those cast iron seals are the optimum solution
for turbo engines.
The silicon nitride ceramic seals are nice but they can be
fractured by detonation as well and they are very expensive.
Paul Lamar
Bill Freeman wrote:
I'll bet the wear characteristics of cast iron with minimal lube
are a whole bunch better than 4130 with minimal lube. I
suspect that the cast iron was selected more for the very
high carbon content in a form which is useful for wear
resistance, rather than it's strength. Brittle appears to be
OK in this application (SiN is brittle, too).
The coated 4130 might be a pretty good deal, assuming
the price is reasonable.
Bill
Long EZ builder & pilot
mechanical engineer
I am trying to get away from the brittle. Perhaps the coating is
more porous and will retain lube oil. Is that the case?
Iannette claims the silicon nitride seals do not wear.
Jim Mederer at RB swears they are excellent.
Can one D-Gun coat with silicon nitride?
These things are only 3 mm wide and 75 mm long so we are not
talking about a whole bunch of area here. Even if we had the
sides coated the seal is only 7 mm high.
Drilling holes in the back with a .1094" drill on .125" spacing
5 mm deep will reduce the mass of the 4130. This is a walk
in the park for a real small (cheap) NC mill. Just another
operation in the cutting of the seal.
I am looking for tough that will withstand a certain amount
of detonation. We could sell them to the drag racers :-)
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org