Subject: Noise from ducted fan stators & eff.
From: Paul
Date: 4/26/2000, 1:17 PM

"Sneed, Glen" wrote:

Paul,
Sorry the link did not work for you.  I just tried it from the this email
and it opened.

What I mean by traditional impellers is, 'the blades contain an airfoil
shape.'  The JetFan has a shape similar to the 'Coke Bottle' shape, i.e. the
F105 Thud fuselage.  The blade cord line goes straight through the center of
the blade.

The blade design allows easier manufacturing.  The shape is constant from
the root to the tip.

The 20-25% increase in exit pressure is achieved without stator.  In fact,
the stators only increase the output pressure by 0-2%.  Therefore, the
addition complexity and weight are not worth the effort.

I agree, stators recover the energy lost to the vortex.  The goal is to
recover more energy than is required recover it.  R/C model ducted fans use
them to achieve greater thrust for the same power, otherwise they would have
greatly reduced performance.

Just because GE, P&W, and RR have not developed this technology does not
mean it isn't valuable.  These large corporation have billions invested in
there R&D of there current designs and technology.  

I don't buy that. If it was possible to make a better ducted fan 
one of them would be doing it. Unlike the rotary engine that is their 
bread and butter. It is not like they have to retool or anything.

Sounds like the 100 MPG carb all over again. I have spent a large 
part of my life in R&D and never ever has a CEO walked in the lab door 
and said to me "suppress that". They frequently say "we can't make
money on that" for various reasons. That is not the case with
the turbofan makers. They can make big money on a better turbofan.
The profits are there for them and the airlines.

Why has not Lycoming or
Continental adopted the DynaCam design piston engine? I am sure you noticed
it at Oshkosh.  That design produces more torque at lower RPM and has a
better BSHP. Which is better? (nothing like having a 12 cylinder under the
bonnet

Why should they? It is not better than what they are making now.

BTW The reason they don't go to rotaries is they can barely make money 
selling what they are making and they are not about to pioneer
the market for rotary aircraft engines. Henry Ford said,  and I 
am paraphrasing; "show me me an innovator and I will show you a 
candidate for bankruptcy". It is also questionable that the advantages
of the rotary out weigh the disadvantages of slightly higher fuel
consumption, PSRU's and liquid cooling complexity.

It will be up to us to develop the market for aircraft rotaries 
and then they will enter it. Just like certified composite airplanes. 
When Lancair and Cirrus start making money, Cessna, Piper and Beech will
not be far behind. And, BTW, probably do a better job. Or perhaps
buy either Cirrus or Lancair :-) Deeper pockets you know.

The Achilles heel of the DynaCam design is the line contact between 
the piston roller and the cam limiting the RPM.  The low RPM/high 
torque feature is a drawback for most existing airplane designs.
It needs a gear box to speed it up :-) It still has exhaust valves. 
Get the ACRE Newsletter CD and read all about it. We have discussed 
it extensively on here. 


I like to think us RotorHeads think outside the box.  We are willing to
experiment with good idea looking for a better, cheaper, simpler mouse trap.
The only thing which is secrete is 'SAFETY'.

Well, enough of the editorial.  Don't shoot the messenger.

Clear Prop,

Glenn Sneed


The laws of physics will not be broken. They are not just a good idea
they are the LAW!!!

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org