Jeff Spitzer wrote:
I've been away for a few days so it was rather interesting to read what a
massive exchange has gone on about cavitation. Here's my understanding and
observations:
Q) What is inlet cavitation?
A) It can occur in any pump any time any local pressure drops below the
boiling point. This has been well covered.
Q) What is outlet cavitation?
A) The wrong name for stalling as noted by H.W. THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS
"OUTLET CAVITATION" The reason this can be said is that the pressure on
the outlet is always higher than the inlet and if the outlet *could*
cavitate the inlet would have already!
Suppose you had a ten foot head on the inlet and you blocked
the outlet. What would you call that? What would the pressure
be across the impeller? I'll bet not much but I will also
bet there will be a bunch of tiny cavitation bubbles.
What about those little pits near the outlet of my pump?
BTW It amazes me they are so strong as to blow little craters in
the aluminum housing. The cast iron impeller shows no signs
of inlet cavitation.
If you have damage around the outer diameter of the pump impeller,
and in the casing, you probably have discharge cavitation.
I am going to take this guy at his word.
He sounds like he has years of experience with centrifugal
pumps. I will let everybody know how it works. If Paul Yaw
wants to test my pump I can send it to him. What sort of test
rig is he building? I hope it has the block and the rad in the
loop as well as the system pressure and temperature of a hard
working engine. In fact I will take it down there and help him
test it. PL
Q) Does the stock pump experience inlet cavitation?
A) Maybe. But it's not the biggest problem. The major problem is inlet
stalling due to highly non-uniform flow caused by the poor housing design.
The impeller is fed most of the water at high velocity on the side opposite
the inlet tube. The impeller experiences recirculating near zero velocity
feed to the impeller adjacent to the feed tube. Running the pump at higher
RPM may cause local pressures to drop in the high velocity side to the
point of cavitation. Most of the poor performance is related to the gross
separation however.
Q) Does restricing the outlet reduce cavitation?
A) Yes, reducing the flow rate causes less pressure drop as the (slower)
flow enters the pump. Bernoulli taught me this.
Q) Will reducing restrictions in the system result in substantial gains in
coolant flow?
A) Not likely. It all depends on the pump curve. On one post by Bill it
was shown that the flow is simply equilibrium between the pump curve and
the system curve. If the curve is rather steep for the pump at the
"current" operating point then small changes in system pressure will result
in large flow changes. My guess (to be determined with pending tests) is
that the pump curve is rather flat at the current point making system
changes rather ineffective at increasing flow. The reason lies in the
cause of the flow limitation. Because the inlet condition is highly
limiting (not related to loop pressure) without fixing the inlet the flow
will not increase much. Put another way: a large reduction in back
pressure will result in a slight increase in flow which in turn will result
in a large increase in pressure drop (or drop in pump performance) at the
inlet thus acheiving equilibrium.
Jeff Spitzer
Paul Yaw can fix my inlet with your fix if you like and try that too.
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org