Subject: Yet another S51 Chev big block loss of power.
From: Paul
Date: 6/17/2000, 9:55 PM


Examination of the wreckage by a Federal Aviation Administration inspector
revealed
that the propeller reduction gear box input shaft had
sheared. When asked about the shaft, the pilot stated that it failed "at
the weakest
point." He added that the failed area was too thin, and
needed to be re-machined. He believed that over an approximate 100 hours of
operation, stress caused the component to fail.


Seems like every S51 ever built has crashed.

Paul Lamar

George Lendich wrote:

What sort of reduction box was that , do you know Paul ?
George (down under)


Yes. It was a huge stright cut spur gear box patterned after the RR Merlin
design except it had rubber bushing torsional isolation damper built into
the flywheel.

Here is an old message on the subject from the ACRE NL Cd.

Size matters!

This is the Godzilla of PSRUs. The total weight of the PSRU using these
parts is 120 pounds! Contrast that to a Ross PSRU using the Ford C6
planetary gears at 35 pounds.  

This PSRU is one of the reasons the Stewart S51 has such a poor empty
weight to gross weight ratio.

I call these things rock crusher gears.

The designer told me the big problem was using engine oil at 220 degrees
F or so. The gears go out of mesh as the huge gear box warms up.

Of course you can't use a planetary PSRU on a upright V8 unless you
lengthen the landing gear to clear the lower prop shaft axis. A
planetary PSRU would work OK in those old OX5 powered biplanes however.

BTW there is a nice picture of the planetary gear box for the new Pratt
& Whitney geared turbofan engine in the May Aerospace Engineering
magazine page 14. The cluster is about 17 inches in diameter and
transmitts 40,000 shp. That's a lot of ponies. They also claim better
than 99% efficiency.

The writer also says that gear stress has "been all but eliminated using
Pratt & Whitney "self-centering" technology." I don't think so. I think
he left a "due to misalignment" phrase out of there someplace.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org

S51-Rock-chrusher-gears.jpg