norm2 wrote:
This dead horse still needs some beating...
You can always add restrictions to the water flow but it is real tough
to reduce the restrictions and increase flow.
The water pump, radiator, engine block, and other related pieces are a
complex SYSTEM! This is not as simple as torque, power, and rpm in a shaft
where you have a straightforward relationship. Flow through the pump is a
function of differential pressure (thus related to restriction in the
system),vapor pressure of the coolant, and impellor rpm. (As well as other
things that I may be overlooking).
Now, Restriction through the rest of the system is a function of passage
sizes, twists and turns, etc.
Heat transfer is a function of the type of flow, differential temperature,
...
I have first hand knowledge of a cooling system where the waterpump rpm was
increased (in an attempt to improve cooling by increasing fan speed) to the
point where there was cavitation on the water pump after several hundred
hours of operation, ultimately costing a product replacement program (big
big $$). The system would have been OK with a different impellor design, or
perhaps a different system restriction. But given that one group of
individual overspeeded the impellor, they pushed the system into a mode of
operation where the pump would cavitate and eventually fail.
I think that the concept of reducing restriction makes sense, so long as you
stay within the sweet spot of the waterpump specs. And I think we may be
dancing close to the edge by running at speeds somewhat higher than where
the pump may have been optimized. I also know that it is not a trivial
matter to do the testing to figure out exactly where you are at.
An analogy to all this is trying to optimize how to build and sell houses
for a profit. The person who believes that selling price is a function of
how many bathrooms there are may try selling houses that are 1000 square
feet with 6 bathrooms. The person who believes that square footage is the
ticket may try selling houses that have one room, but are very large. The
person who believes that bedrooms is the ticket may build a house with many,
many tiny bedrooms. In moderation, each one of these views is correct.
When taken to far from normal conditions, the philosophy falls apart and you
have problems.
Now, cooling is not a religious concept, the system performs according to
physical laws and principles. But it is a very complicated system. The
challenge that we have is to put together a system that works the first
time, and to do so without the benefit of all of the data of the components
that we are working with. I think that it makes sense to keep the
restriction as low as resonable (you can always put a restrictor plate back
in, but how would you know that your system needs that?), it makes sense to
use as large a radiator and oil cooler as you can (without going too far on
weight and such), and then to balance out the water pump rpm so that it
works. My thoughts are that the pump is spinning plenty fast at 5500 engine
rpm. I just ordered the dual belt pulley set that slows down the waterpump
and the alternator. We'll see how it works when I fire it up!
I also recognize that when it comes to internet web groups, the phrase 'In
My Humble Opinion' is not used frequently enough! The trick is to sort the
good stuff from the junk. In the meantime, the talkers can keep talking,
the builders can keep building, and the flyers can fly!
Regards-
Norm Muzzy
Who me? I am a builder :-)
Paul Lamar
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org