Subject: Renault -diesel fuel consumption.
From: Paul
Date: 7/17/2000, 5:17 AM

Wrathall Mark wrote:

Paul, Why would this be? Diesels are not throttled as such, and the
renault/Sochata diesel is turbocharged. Why would it be altitude sensitive
unless the turbo charging is so mild as to give full rated power up to 10K
only.

The advantage in Europe will still be there as Avgas costs right now
$5.11/gallon whereas Jet A1 costs $2.62/gallon on GA fields and about
0.80c/gallon to the airlines. The difference on the graph is also still
around 8% above 10000' adding to the saving. Another factor is that most GA
is flown here below 10000'. The high dollar has also hurt the price of
LYcon's and their parts.

A Robin got damaged during towing at a field here a month ago, and they are
definatly looking at a Diesel STC as the replcament for the Porsche it had
in it. As small as the european GA market is, I would pick that the Sochata
diesel will be very successful here.

Mark Wrathall

I have no real idea what the French are doing with that engine
and what they are comparing it to. They may be comparing the turbo
version to a lower power NA engine. 
That seems to be the case in the very next chart. It seems
the Renault turbo engine is derated to 300 HP at sea level to equal
a 300 HP NA "traditional" engine. Too many charts and graphs in that
brochure with too little explanation. For example; no where in the
brochure is the weight given. That is a critical number.
all they say is it has a better power to weight ratio.

The 250 and 300 HP models are geared engines. The gear ratio is 3:2.
Historically geared engines have a much lower TBO than their
claimed 3000 hours. What do the French know about gears that the
rest of the world does not?

They are not giving out the BSFC which is the world wide standard 
for this sort of thing. A wee bit slim ball for my engineering mind. 
More oriented to selling the engine to the un-informed. Perhaps just 
French logic. There are telephone numbers; 01 69 12 58 00 or 
or 01 49 34 69 82 Perhaps you can get some later information.

They will sell the heck out of them in Europe no doubt because 
of the extremely low cost of diesel fuel compared to gasoline.
What would happen in the states however where there is not such
a big price difference? The tax structure in Europe could change overnight.
When everybody is running diesel fuel in their cars the politicians
could decide to raise the taxes on diesel fuel. Also in many parts of
the world avgas is not available. Many Lyc's and Cont's can be made to run
on low octane auto gas however by lowering the compression ratio.

Paul Lamar
 
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org