Bill Freeman wrote:
Paul,
I did indeed get to the Powersport exhibit and was intriqued
by their approach to the gearbox problem. They have
basically taken the 15 lb sledghammer approach, which will
probably be good. I would have to reserve final judgement
until I see a fast fourier transform of the vibration data
from that system, so I can see where the first nat freq is
located relative to the driving functions. The coolest part is
the slick way they supported the overhung bearing on the
pinion. Pretty cool engineering job and my eyeball is satisfied.
I at first thought they blew it like everybody else and had
and overhung pinion. Finally saw the housing and took
a minute to figure out what that funny thing was in the
middle of the pinon's location. Finally - well DUH! Good
idea!
Basically there are two ways to beat the vibration demon.
Well actually, three. One is to test the system very carefully
and make sure you are not going to OPERATE at or near
a harmonic resonance. You can pass thru them, but just
don't operate there. This is used on my Dad's Mooney
Executive with a non-torsional pendulum'ed crankshaft,
you must not operate above 1900 or below 2400 (I think)
RPMs. Works but can be a pain.
The second method is to detune or decouple the system so
the torsional harmonics are canceled or cannot travel the full
ength of the system. The torsional pendulums on some 4 cyl
and nearly all 6 cyl A/C engines tune out some of these. The
rubber bushings or clutch disks decouple the system into
two parts, preventing most problems.
The third way is to make the whole system so ultra stiff
in torsion that the first resonance is well above any of
the driving functions and just brute force it - the bigger
hammer approach. Can work in smaller gearboxes like this
one, but you better be damned sure you got it high enough
or "bang". Needs good testing to verify, but when done
right can be very good. This way costs some weight, which
is why methods one and two are more common. This method
is also often very impractical for larger industrial gearboxes due
to the extreme shaft sizes that it would require.
Bill
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org