Howard wrote:
Paul:
Torque and RPM are very easy to measure and are unaffected by
atmospheric conditions and all that stuff..... engine performance is
affected, but the actual meaured output is not. A scale, strain guage or
whatever read the same regardless or at least can be calibrated.
An arbitrary sea level standard x degree day with humidity of y% should
be the standard test environment...... The only variations that make any
sense are the result of differing standard conditions from one part of the
world to another. Testing in a controlled environment... a test cell for
example makes sense.......operating in excess of sea level standard
pressure
is deceptive.
I live at 5000' and I believe horsepower degradation is in the
neighborhood of 20% from sea level..... The difference between SAE and DIN
is at least 15%... perhaps as much as 20%. I find it difficult if not
impossible to justify differences of this magnitude between Detroit
Michigan
and Stuttgart..... I stand by my assertion that it is a matter of clever
rationalization of deceptive numbers.
The level playing field is the only way to compare figures from
different companies and get useful results. To suggest that
manufacturers
who spend millions of dollars to develop engines cannot manage to
accomplish
these tests under more or less standard conditions is absurd in my
opinion...... If I wanted to make my engine look good I'd wait for a cool
day when atmospheric pressure was high......
GDI has two major applications. One is to make two cycle engines smog
free, and the other is to allow true stratified charge so an engine can run
under a lean condition which leaves more air in the cylinder to expand from
the heat of combustion as well as reducing pumping losses due to a partly
closed throttle {throttle is not closed as much}. In the stratified
charge application on 4 cycle engines GDI will indeed reduce power output.
Two strategies have been developed to overcome the loss of high end power.
The simplest is dual injectors.... at light loads where GDI offers real
benefit in economy... typical automotive cruise loads, direct injecton
timed
right before spark is used with a strategically shaped piston. Under
heavy loads port injection is used.... no problem... The other strategy
is a timing change and may or may not include a variable spray pattern.
In automotive the main concern is to maximize cruise efficiency and
minimize emissions... GDI is very capable of this.
Here are some links (below) on GDI for the fellow who was asking....they
may
be out of date as I haven't been to any of them for awhile. Orbital of
Australia is the oldest and best known of these.... they designed the
system
used on the Mercury Optimax outboard engine which is the only GDI engine
available to my knowledge to the public in the US. These two cycle
engines
are available up to 250 HP as I recall, and are quite efficient and
dependable. Siemens makes the injectors in cahoots with Orbital.
Mitsubishi is the only auto manufacturer that I know of who has GDI cars on
the road... but not in the US yet.
H.W.
http://www.mitsubishi-motors.co.jp/inter/technology/GDI/
http://www.mitsubishi-motors.co.jp/GDI2000/
http://www.orbeng.com.au/
http://www.princeton.edu/~felton/&id=26&userid=2g4lodpmoHg6&query=MT=Direct
+
Injection&SM=phrase&DC=100&RG=NA
http://www.frostbyte.com/siemens/siemens/powertrain/ec_gehp5.html&id=24&use
r
id=2g4lodpmoHg6&query=MT=Direct+Injection&SM=phrase&DC=100&RG=NA
http://www.mitsubishi-motors.co.jp/MOTORSHOW/TMS/seminar/index.html
That is a good post Howard - and shifting to port injection at full
power will indeed overide the objection that I stated - and is an easy
fix that manufactures will undoubtedly use.
The SAE corrections if properly used could allow an apples to apples
dyno test at your 5000 ft altitude. The primary problem with power
ratings coming from both Detroit and Germany (and others) is that
specifications are released by the marketing and advertizing departments
rather than engineering. Mercury outboard people used a reverse of this
technique in early days when they rated their 20 cubic inch engine as a
10HP when it really was about 18, and the so called 25 which was close
to 40. Boaters around the world still say "Them Mercs put out a lot more
power than any of them other guys" - Vance
The Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org