MAR34807@aol.com wrote:
UPDATE ON LAST WEEK'S 206H ACCIDENT...
Last week I mentioned a 1999 normally aspirated 206H accident in
Western New York where initial reports had the aircraft catching fire
in flight. The pilot made an emergency landing in a field and the
aircraft was destroyed by fire. The pilot suffered spinal injuries but
is expected to recover. Such an event draws a great amount of concern
and the FAA, Cessna and Lycoming all sent people out to investigate.
Fortunately it does not appear that this accident was related to design
or manufacture.
While it will take weeks or months for the NTSB to finalize the
probable cause of the accident, here is what appears to be the most
likely scenario.
The engine developed an oil leak, the cause of which we will discuss
a bit further on. This caused oil to get on the exhaust producing a
significant amount of smoke. The pilot probably took this smoke as an
indication of an engine compartment fire, a reasonable assumption.
Actually, at this point there probably was no fire, just smoke.
As the oil leak continued the oil level in the engine got so low
that the engine was lacking for lubrication. Lack of lubrication
caused a connecting rod to fail and punch a hole in the case. This was
the bang/boom noise/vibration that the pilot thought was an explosion.
It may have also dislodged the cowling, though the cowling did not
depart the aircraft in flight. With a failed engine, smoke and limited
visibility, the pilot was able to plant the aircraft in a field and
survive. As the aircraft only moved about 40 feet after initial impact
obviously the vertical component was quite high and thus the spinal
injuries to the pilot. This high impact load also caused damage to the
front-end, which allowed fuel to feed a fire that probably started on
impact and thus consumed a significant part of the aircraft.
What caused the oil leak? Without pointing fingers the post
accident investigation seems to indicate that oil was coming from the
area of the dip stick/filler spout. There were no signs of leaks in
other areas. Other items of significance that turned up during the
investigation is that the cowling sections were found with the airframe
which means that the cowling did not blow off in flight, though it
certainly could have popped at least partially open. Also, tear down
of the engine showed signs of lack of lubrication throughout which
means that lack of lubrication most likely caused the connecting rod
failure. The aircraft had about 350 hours on it which meant that it
had been through several inspections. An odd note is that the aircraft
had been topped about 100 hours ago under warranty for high oil
consumption. Whether this could have played a role is still being
looked at.
Did the pilot leave the dipstick loose or fail to check it on pre-
flight? Only he might know and probably doesn't recall. And of
course, though less likely, there could be other possibilities for an
oil leak in the area of the dip stick such as seal failure, high
crankcase pressure, thread failure on the cap, etc.
I know how easily one can fail to get an oil cap on because I have
done it. A few years ago I took off on an IFR flight and about an hour
into the flight noticed oil on the windshield. Fortunately it was
daylight in VFR conditions so I was able to land at the closest
airport. Sure enough the oil cap was dangling on its chain and the
engine compartment was covered with oil. Because I had picked up on
the problem before there was a drop in oil pressure, no damage was
done, but I can certainly appreciate how this sort of thing can happen.
It is never a pleasant thing reviewing accident/incident
investigations as I must. However, it was a relief to see that this
accident, which at first looked like it could have significant
ramifications for at least the fleet of 206H aircraft, turned out to
have an explanation that did not relate to design or manufacture.
I have left my oil cap off too on my C182. Same thing happened.
I landed quickly and put it back on.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org