Douglas E. Dempsey
Bellvue, CO 80512
970-221-0261
How much will 37 gal per minute of water/glycol mix cool??
* Water: 62.4 lb./cu.ft ; 7.48 gal./cu. ft. ;
therefore 8.34 lb./gal of water
* 2,545 BTU/hr. = 1 HP
* 1 BTU/hr. = 1 lb (h2o) x 1 deg. (F)
****** Specific heat of 50:50 mixture of glycol:h2o = 0.5******
therefore: 1 BTU/hr. = 2 lb (mix) 1 deg(F)/hr.
Given: 37 gal/min. circulation in a closed system. (Gauge pressure of
operating system effects the vapor pressure but does not significantly
[alter] the ability to absorb transferred heat, just allows it to not boil
until a higher temperature...if you like that!)
37 gal/min x 8.34 lb./gal. = 308.6 lb./min.;
308.6 x 60 min./hr. = 18,515 lb./hr.
*Assume a desired temperature rise through the engine of:
20 deg. F, ie..180 in - 200 out.
18,515 lb./hr. x 20 deg (F) = 370,000 lb. (mix) deg (F)/hr.
370,000 lb. (mix) deg (F)/ hr./2 lb.(mix) deg (F)/hr./BTU = 185,150 BTU/hr.
185,150 BTU/hr/2,545 BTU/hr./HP = 72.75 HP of heat accepted by water/glycol
mix.
Per [given] Heat Balance of Rotary Engine,
% of Total heat rejected to water = ~ 17%
72.75 HP/.17 = 427.9 HP Total energy in via fuel............10.9 gph of 91
oct gasoline.
Per [given] Heat Balance of Rotary Engine,
% of Total heat goes to useful work =~ 28%
**427.9 x .28 = 120 HP of engine output.........(10.9 gph @ .55 BSFC!!)
THEREFORE: 37 gpm of a 50:50 water:glycol mix with a 20 deg. F rise through
the engine will cool 120 HP of output from a typical Mazda rotary engine.
In order to cool 215 HP of Mazda rotary one must:
1.Flow 215/120 x 37 gpm = 66 gpm of 50:50 glycol/water, or
2.Accept a temp, differential of 215/120 x (20 deg F) = 36.8 deg F.
or
3.Use water only and freeze up the engine when the OAT reaches 31.5 deg F!
****Either must be used with a radiator system (separate, but related issue)
which will transfer: 215/120 x 185,150 = 331,727 BTU/hr.....
...and an oil cooler capable of cooling the oil to operating
temperatures (approx. 150,000 BTU's/hr.)
Note: If radiator is capable of transferring in excess of the required amount
of heat transferred to the liquid, the inlet temperature to the engine (outlet
temperature of the radiator system) may indeed be 180 deg F. However,
the 37 gpm will require the 36.8 deg temperature rise...180 deg F in -
216 deg F out of engine.
One cannot stuff more BTU/hr. into that amount of water at that temperature
differential. Nucleate boiling may get it into mixture, but if the mass flow
rate doesn't increase the temperature differential must increase. However,
this increased temperature differential will also cause more BTU/hr. being
transferred to the oil. If [the oil] is capable, it will absorb an additional
amount equal to the now increased temperature differential of the oil.
If the oil cooler has excess capacity, this will decrease the temperature of
the oil and will assist the water cooling system and reduce the amount of
heat transferred to the water, thus reducing the temperature differential of
the 37 gpm of water flowing through the system. Still not a good situation.
The temperature differential of the water and oil should have their own
preferred amounts dependent upon a number of operating characteristics of the
fluids and engine system working together. Many examples show preferred
temperature differentials of 20 deg F for the water and oil, with 40 deg F
being the maximum allowable for satisfactory operation.
I have no idea for
what extended period of time one should feel comfortable with higher
temperatures, but I don't like it at all when I am more than 2' off the
ground! But hey, sometimes the mountain side is getting closer or that
antennea is looming, so pay your money and take your choice! That is when I
begin to question the life of really hot bouncing valves and low viscosity
oil going through bearings being subjected to stop/start power strokes.
Personal note: Have any of you attempted to ground run their 200 HP Lyc
IO-360 at max output??
Even at 5,000 ft airport altitude (83%), the temperature will
zoom to the redline in less than 5 min. Furthermore at 100 deg F, My Mooney
M20F has never been able to climb at anything remotely close to max rate
without the temperatures going to the redline and past (haven't yet had to
find out)!!
The required technique: As soon as possible ie..(too low for comfort):
1. lower the nose,
2. Accelerate to at least 120 mph, reduce power to at least 75%,
3. Sweat while you struggle juggling the cylinder
head temp (425 deg, normal 375 deg), oil temp (220 deg, normal 190 deg) and
the frightfully low oil pressure (50+ psi in the yellow, normal 72 psi ) with
air speed/power output as your only weapons.
It [the Lyc] may cost $15,000 to just overhaul, but it is still one very marginal
powerplant unless run absolutely by the numbers. It will run BSFC = .45
everyday, all the time. Why shouldn't it? WOT putting out .42 HP/cu. in.!
I really can't complain. It has carried me and my family over 300,000 miles
without outright failure thanks to lots of preventive maintenance.
I have done some very interesting cooling system comparisons between the
Mooney M20F with its cowl openings and oil cooler system and that which would
be required for the 13B and 20B systems. It is certainly directional and
hits very close to the center of the target for what will work for the Mazda
rotaries and pointing out what is destined to be an ongoing problem. I will
add it when it is condensed and typed.
Doug Dempsey
Bellvue, CO
(Checkbook out, but can't decide whether to go Murphy SR2500:20B or RV-8
w13BT)
Wonderful upload Doug. Thanks. I was just telling (and thanking) Ray that
his coolant pump flow data was going to lead to a better understanding of
the Mazda cooling system. All evidence leads to the need for more coolant
flow.
Thanks again Doug.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org