Subject: Cooling a Rotary coolant mass flow capacity
From: Paul
Date: 9/18/2000, 10:39 AM

norm2 wrote:

THEREFORE:  37 gpm of a 50:50 water:glycol mix with a 20 deg. F rise
through
the engine will cool 120 HP of output from a typical Mazda rotary engine.

This is good news for the majority of general aviation folks considering the
application of a rotary engine!  If you look at the performance specs for
most general aviation aircraft that use engines from 160 to 200 hp, you will
see that the performance increase is real, but perhaps not that significant.
120 HP = 75% power from a 160 hp engine, or ~65% power from a 180 hp engine.
So, for the vast majority of experimental aircraft that are being built
today, we have a powerplant that will cut the mustard.  Very equivalent to
an O-320 or O-360 (given good installation practice).

In order to cool 215 HP of Mazda rotary one must:


Now we are getting into that region about equivalent to racing.  215 hp is
equivalent to a 285 HP engine at 75% power. That looks like a really big
aircraft engine.  Put an engine like that in your RV6, and you will need
some larger cowlings and more airflow to keep everything cool.  Same thing
on a rotary.  If you want to cool at the horsepower, it is going to take a
lot of coolant flow, air flow, and delta T.  Fortunately, most people are
going to put a 285 horsepower engine into their aircraft,  So the rotary
should do just fine.

Personal note:  Have any of you attempted to ground run their 200 HP Lyc
IO-360 at max output??

So, maybe we can rely on the horsepower capability of the rotary for
superior climbout performance, accepting the condition that we may have to
throttle back to the limitations of our cooling system.

I really can't complain.  It has carried me and my family over 300,000
miles
without outright failure thanks to lots of preventive maintenance.

And here is where we need to be realistic about any aircraft engine
installation.  It has to be done right.  It has to be taken care of.  It is
unrealistic to assume that you can go to the junk yard, buy $500 worth of
engines, coolers, and evaporator cores, bolt it into an airframe and have
something that performs like a 300 hp aircraft engine.  There is some kind
of transfer function at work here that says if you want to use a relatively
stock rotary, with common oil coolers and radiators, you can get x amount of
horsepower for y amount of dollars.  Start cranking up the required
horsepower, and now you start to need special induction systems, better
waterpumps, higher performance cooling packages, etc.

There are some parallels to car racing here as well. I am not a racer, but
have been around and helped out enough to have some feel for how it works.
If you want to drag race cars, you can run a car that is considered 'slow',
but it can be a lot of fun, very reliable, and be very straightforward to
build, maintain, and operate.  Carve another second off the ET, and you get
to spend more money, more maintenance, and less reliability.  And it will
take a higher skilled operator to get the max performance out of the
vehicle.  How much does it cost to take the next second of the ET?  And the
next one?  Not too many steps, and you are on TV on Sundays!

Certainly on this list we have a number of individuals who are aspiring to
build airplanes that would be equivalent to the Reno racers.  And they will
have to deal with the big dollars, the engineering, and everything else that
goes into running out on the ragged edge of physics, machinery, and operator
abilities.  At the other end we have a number of people who only need 100
hp.  Their challenge is that the rotary engine has an inherent weight
associated with it, and it may be too heavy for their airframe capabilities.

So, at the bottom end, we can compare the weight of the rotary with the
Lycomings and come up with a generalized statement that says 'the rotary is
a reasonable replacement for the O-320 type engines'.  (Or some other
engine, you experts can figure out how small you want to go before the
weight gets you in trouble).  Then, from that 160 hp (120 @75% power) point
on up, we can assume that we have a good fit for the application, if we can
get the engine to run reliably.  This includes the cooling, induction, and
exhaust systems.  Once we get to an upper limit (perhaps around that 200 hp
range), we hit limits on what the engine package as it comes from the
factory is capable of.  Now we get to start doing some serious engineering,
spending som more money, and dealing with those knife edge tradeoffs of
weight, horsepower, and reliability.  Special water pumps, custom radiators,
exotic materials, etc.


 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org