Guys, in my previous life, I did a lot of pump testing and hydraulics work, so I
can say with assurance that I know enough to be dangerous. The way I think about
the water pumping system is that the engine is essentially a fixed nozzle which
you're trying pump a varying amount of water through, depending on pump speed.
What you find is that at higher pump speeds, you just can't get that much
additional volume thru the "nozzle", even though the pressure is increasing. The
radiators also can lower the size of the "fixed nozzle", if there is significant
resistance (pres loss) to high flow. If you were to look at a flow/pressure
curves vs rpm pump/engine, I think you would see this happening.
The Nascar guys slow down their water pumps because their engines are run at
7-8,000 rpm which is much higher than the stock design max 6,000 rpm. I've been
told that they do this to avoid cavitation (inlet vacuum on backside of pump
blade due to pressure loss thru the system), and it's more efficient. In our
aircraft situation, we are working within the original design parameters in that
we're operating at less than 6,500 rpm, so I don't think we need to slow down
the pump (but I could be wrong, if someone actually does the testing). Also, I
would question that increasing the pump speed would gain us anything worthwhile
because we're still stuck with that fixed nozzle situation.
I think it's important that we size the radiators so that there aren't
restrictive to flow, but more importantly, that there be adequate area (and
volume) to cool the engine under worst case conditions. The airflow thru the
radiator (quantity and speed) is the big factor that determines radiator
adequacy.
Chuck
I totally agree with you Chuck. Most of our cooling failures so far have
been due to improperly ducted and located radiators. When done properly
I think we can get away with 500 cubic inches and two inches thick based on
what Chuck Dunlap has learned.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org