Paul and All,
Here is my opinion on the lubrication problem with
the 2.17 as compared with the 2.85 Ross.In stock
configuration both depend both spray a low level of oil
in bottom of gear housing before drain back to oil
sump.Those who have run both ratios know there is a fine
line between to much in as opposed to the drain back
rate. Too large an orifice in(normally about .040)and you
start pressurizing the housing and the result is oil
leaks from the rear and or front seals. Too small an
orifice and you risk both bearings and gears.I believe
that with the .040 both ratios get about the same volume
of lubrication so why does the 2.17 not oil as well as
the 2.85?
Here is my 2 cents !
To those not familiar with the Ross boxes here is a
short(Hopefully)course on their main differences.
The 2.17 Ross has its ring gear welded to the output
(prop)shaft and the planet housing fixed. The sun gear
(driven by input shaft)drives the planet pinions which
then drives the ring gear which turns your prop.In my
opinion here is where the lubrication problem lurks.The
ring gear is spinning at output(prop)rpm and throwing
oil away from itself,planet pinions and sun gear from
centrifical force.
The 2.85 Ross has its ring gear fixed to the gear-
box housing and the planet housing(carrier)bolted to the
output(prop)shaft.The sun gear(driven by input shaft)
drives the planet pinions which revolve around the fixed
ring gear driving planet housing(and your prop).Here
lies the lubrication difference between the two PSRUs.
The fixed ring gear is being sprayed with oil and most
likely has a small buildup of same in bottom of housing.
The planet carrier and its pinions are constantly
running in this lubrication. The pinions pick up this
oil,lube themselves and in turn lube the driving sun
gear.
Hope this makes sense and if I am off base please
let me know.I have 2.85 Ross and I sure wish someone
would figure how to put a thrust bearing on the input
shaft.
Kelly Troyer
--
Dyke Delta/13B Rotary Power
Chuck and I had a long talk on the phone awhile ago. The gist of that
was Chuck saw unsymetrical gear wear in the 2.17:1. He also noticed that Ross
locked down the planet carrier. One of his modifications was to
let the planet carrier float. So there was no real evidense that
the 2.17:1 gears were not getting enough oil. You cannot make two modifications
and expect to determine which solves the problem. Tracy ran the 2.17:1
for 650 hours. It destroyed his 13B thrust bearing. He decided he could
improve the oiling as well as add a thrust bearing so he did.
IMHO the jury is still out on the need to improve the gear oiling on
the 2.17:1 Ross. When we see more boxes with 500 hours or so
with floating planet carriers and evenly worn gears than I will admit
at that time the oiling needs improving.
If yours is the 2.85:1 you may not need the thrust bearing. I am not sure
about that untill I see one of each side by side disassembled.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org