Subject: My 2 cents on Ross PSRU
From: Paul
Date: 11/3/2000, 11:20 AM

charles.harbert@fmglobal.com wrote:

Chuck and I had a long talk on the phone awhile ago. The gist of that
was Chuck saw unsymetrical  gear wear in the 2.17:1. He also noticed that
Ross
locked down the planet carrier. One of his modifications was to
let the planet carrier float. So there was no real evidense that
the 2.17:1 gears were not getting enough oil. You cannot make two
modifications
and expect to determine which solves the problem. Tracy ran the 2.17:1
for 650 hours. It destroyed his 13B thrust bearing.  He decided he could
improve the oiling as well as add a thrust bearing so he did.
IMHO the jury is still out on the need to improve the gear oiling on
the 2.17:1 Ross. When we see more boxes with 500 hours or so
with floating planet carriers and evenly worn gears than I will admit
at that time the oiling needs improving.

If yours is the 2.85:1 you may not need the thrust bearing. I am not sure
about that untill I see one of each side by side disassembled.

Paul Lamar

Paul, you're correct in that we did see asymetrical wear, but I also had
very high temperature (50-60 degF) increase as the oil went thru the box
which was indicating metal to metal contact. I spoke with a gear
lubrication expert (former Exxon Chief Lube Engr) who said that kind of
increase was unacceptable, and that I needed more oil directly to the
pinion and planetaries, plus better oil. After the gbox mods, my temp
increase was only 20-30 degF increase, and my wear pattern stabilized (or
seemed to) after additional flights. As you know, you must also increase
the oil supply and pump the oil out of the unit.

The problem seems to be the high centifugal forces (2-3,000 rpm at the ring
gear) keeping the oil from being transferred to the high loaded, high rpm
pinion and planetaries. The 2.86 has a fixed ring allowing the planetaries
to roll around in the oil continually which may be why it's lasting longer.
Dave Atkins lost the gears in his original 2.86 Ross, then switched to a
2.17 many yrs ago. He's got over 100 hrs (cross country 3 times) on his
after the mods and on teardown it looks good. Oil temps are down and the
filter is clean.  .

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org