Hello Paul,
I decided to e-mail you rather than reply on the main page in order
to keep traffic down. My question concerns the helical gear and why it
doesn't create the same problems in cars that we see in re-drives? It looks
to me like a helical gear is going to create thrust no matter what it's
geared to and probably encounter the same bearing problems regardless of the
application? I'm no mechanic or engineer so I've probably missed something
like the forest for the trees, but maybe you can explain this in a way a
novice can understand.
Thanks,
Robin
No problem with traffic Robin. I appreciate all questions so we can clear
up
this issue.
You are absolutely correct when you state "It looks to me like a helical
gear
is going to create thrust no matter what it's geared to and probably
encounter
the same bearing problems regardless of the application?"
The answer is in the Ford C6 auto transmissions in the form
of thrust bearings designed to take these gear thrust loads. Unfortunately
Lou
Ross overlooked these thrust loads when he adapted the Ford C6 planetary
gear
set. I am sure Ford felt the troubles with helical gears were worth it
for the other advantages namely, quieter and stronger.
A straight cut planetary gear set would be better for our application
but right at the moment we have not found a low cost suitable set.
Paul Lamar
Tracy Crook wrote:
All true Paul.. There is also the factor that in the car, the helical gears
are only loaded while in low, second or reverse gear. The vast majority of
the time the transmission is in high gear (and low throttle) which unloads
the planetaries in the C6. Not the case with newer transmissions which
have overdrive.
GM makes a rare version of the Turbo 400 with straight cut gears. Cost is
$700 + for a set of gears and used ones are rare as hens teeth. The
transmission repair folks tell me that the straight cut versions give a lot
more trouble with failing gears than the helical version but no thrust
bearing failures. Still not a good trade IMHO. Helical gears virtually
never fail (in automobiles) unless another failure sends metal debris into
the planetary set.
Haven't had time to do pictures etc but I completed the new exhaust system.
Can't say how pleased I am with the sound and performance. I'll never put
the muffler under the cowl again after seeing & hearing the difference. The
header pipes are a bit short of the theoretical best 32" (29" & 28") but the
improvement in power is obvious. I hate the idea of the muffler being out
there creating drag but it must not be too bad because top speed is up a few
MPH and econo cruise fuel burn is down. It is not quite as quiet as the
tangential muffler when it was new but the character of the sound (hard to
describe) is so much nicer that I don't mind. CD player (I just switched
to an MP3 player actually) is enjoyable again. Nice to be able to use an
off the shelf muffler instead of that 4 day ordeal I had making the other
one.
The 20B powered RV-8 FWF design is going well. I feel like I died & went to
heaven with all that room under the cowl (compared to the -4). I just got
the radiator (a single Griffin) which will be mounted on the left side of
the engine. Had originally planed to do a P-51 style cooling system but
changed my mind. The oil cooler will go on the right similar to what I have
on the -4.
Just got the prototype 6 planet carrier (for 20B version of the RD-1(A))
from John Moran and it looks good. Will install it on the -4 for initial
testing. Will upload some pictures of all this stuff soon. Back to
making metal chips........
Tracy Crook
rws@altavista.net
www.rotaryaviation.com
Thanks for jumping in here and helping me out on this Tracy :-)
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org