Paul,
I agree with you that the tangential muffler could be very efficient,
however
based on input from an engineer friend, and Finn's experience, and
Tracy's
with the 1000 hour life with an 0.035 stainless muffler, I have come to
the
following position.
1. A tangential muffler with short pipes close coupled to the engine is
likely to fail due to differential thermal expansion causing the welded
joint
at the tangential pipe to the muffler to be fatigued. Finn had a
failure
like this. My engineer friend had multiple failures like this when
working
on a close-coupled exhaust thermal reactor at Ford.
2. The same muffler mounted a couple of feet away has lasted a long time
(Tracy). IMHO, this is because the longer exhaust header pipes allow
more
movement as the muffler heats up, and reduces the stress on the
pipe-muffler
joint.
3. Problem #1 can be avoided by the use of bellows for expansion relief
(expensive) or by approach #2.
4. Chuck Dunlap's muffler also avoids this problem, and I believe that
you
commented that it was very quiet.
My current choice, a tangential muffler located like Tracy's or Chuck's.
Bill Schertz
I don't agree that it will necessarily crack. In any case
no problem. Just put a large slip joint in the muffler itself.
I'll make a drawing soon.
BTW Dave Atkins has been flying with one made from thin Inconel for at
least 400 hours.
As I recall it weighs four pounds less the flange.
Paul Lamar
Jeff Spitzer wrote:
The one you showed won't crack 'cause it uses the heavy one-piece racing
beat flange. I'd guess that the one that failed (Finn's?) used separate
flanges.
Jeff Spitzer
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org