Subject: Photo of coolant leak culprit
From: Paul
Date: 12/28/2000, 8:53 PM


After looking at this list of compatible chemicals with Creavy Teflon
encapsulated silicone O-rings I smell a rat.
My memory was jogged. This happened once before about a couple of years
ago with a certain person. I think I know who it was/is. Perhaps that rumor
got started by someone with a large inventory of after market Viton oil
O-rings for rotary engines. I doubt seriously that hot motor oil will degrade
these O-rings given this list of compatible chemicals. Note that gasoline
is on the list. It is easy to check. I will cook one in hot oil soon.

Paul Lamar



Mike Wills wrote:
  Just a few weeks ago I posted a link to a website belonging to an
acquiatance of mine. I believe he is a chemical/materials engineer by trade
and an RX7 enthusiast as well. He has a nice 94 RX7 mildly hot rodded. He
did some testing with motor oil exposure to silicone, viton, and neoprene
hoses and those tests are documented on the website.

  Note there is no reference to teflon encapsulated O-rings but he did
specifically mention these to me. His concern as I recall is with past
experience with porosity in teflon coatings in other applications. He has
never run a similar test on O-rings. I suppose the best way to verify the
applicability is to run a similar independant test using the O-rings rather
than hoses. Meanwhile I would be extremely careful about using silicone
where the possibility of exposure to motor oil exists.

  This guy has no financial interest in this as implied above, he just
didnt want to see me kill myself which I appreciate very much. The web link
is: http://geocities.com/sdrx7_club/hosetest.pdf

Mike Wills

I agree on the bare silicone Mike and that perhaps is one reason the bare silicone 
water O rings turn to brown dust on ten or fifteen year old Mazda  rotary engines.

On the other hand Teflon lined double stainless steel braided brake line hoses 
are rated over 3000 psi without leaking. I believe the Creavy list assumes
the teflon is effective in protecting the silicone from chemicals.
I think Creavy could get in big legal trouble if someone takes them at 
their word and it does not work. I also believe that Creavy knows that
all too well.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org