Subject: Universal motor mount plate for Tracy's redrive?
From: Paul
Date: 1/4/2001, 4:21 PM


marc wiese wrote:

OK, Paul, you have convinced me that this may be a good idea.
Put me on the list for one. However, if possible, please DON'T cut any
of
the starter holes in mine. I will be making other provisions for that.
Marc Wiese


I don't know if we can do that Marc. When we get them Hydra Cut it is done
by computer out of one huge 4' by 12' plate of 1/2 inch thick 6061 T6
aluminum.
You might want to cut your own in a case like that. My leanings
are for the starter to be on a horizontal line through the e-shaft
center line off to the exhaust side. Only minor up and down
repositioning is possible. As I recall the 10 mm mounting bolts
get in the way on the ignition side. The starter in both cases
projects forward along side Tracy's redrive.

Paul Lamar



Tracy Crook wrote:

Since a number of builders are deciding to go this route and to answer a few
inquires about this plate I guess I need to get something on record about
it.

This plate may work out just fine for some applications and I think Paul is
correct in saying that there is no danger of the thing breaking due to the
loads imposed by mounting the engine this way.  I do have some reservations
however.

1.   The success of the drive is very  dependant on the precision of this
plate (and the spacers) to keep all the moving parts concentric.  It might
be fine but be aware that I have no control over this.

2.    I don't have a problem with moving the starter location but using it
for the engine mount is another matter. The loads on the plate and spacers
when using it for an engine mount probably will not break anything but I do
not know if it will it cause enough deflection to upset concentricity.  This
is especially true since some are even planning on using different spacers.

3.  The jury is still out on these two but I'm not sure it is an efficient
mounting system in terms of weight.  I am also in doubt about the logic
being presented on the subject of vibration isolation.  Definitely not an
expert on the subject here but it bears some study.

4.  Since I am not involved, there is no coordination with ongoing design
changes being made to the drive.  As an example, the current version of my
adapter plate has a shallow counterbore on the gearhousing side for the
thrust bearing race.  This is a recent change that was made after the
"Universal plate" project was started.  This particular change can be
compensated for by either putting the counterbore in the plate or by
decreasing the thickness of the nylon snubber washer to bring the input
shaft end play back to original specs. I simply do not have the time to
coordinate this kind of thing and would not want to assume the liability for
something which I have no control over even if I did.  For this reason,  I
can not warranty any drive used with anything other than the adapter plate
that I furnish.

It goes without saying that none of this is meant to discourage innovation
or experimentation.  Its just a good idea to understand all the
ramifications before setting off on a new course.

Tracy Crook
rws@altavista.net
www.rotaryaviation.com

I don't fault you for taking that position. I would do the same if I were
in your shoes Tracy.

Send me a sketch of that counter bore Tracy and I will accommodate it in
the drawing. If some of you wish to wait until I test it a bit that's fine.

As far as the vibration isolation I think Jeff's analysis is flawed.
Engines don't rotate one degree no matter what. Angular deflection 
due to torque pulses depends on the restraint. 

The torque pulse amplitude however is constant at a give HP level. With wide spread
rubber bushing of the same rate the torque pulses are half the amplitude 
therefor the deflection of the rubber is half as much. Torque is in foot pounds.
200 foot pounds is 200 pounds at a one foot radius and 100 pounds at
a two foot radius. Something Jeff did not point out.

Also the normal 1 G load on the spacers is less with the motor mount plate 
because if you put the motor mounts on the engine the spacers must accommodate 
prop torque which is roughly twice as much as engine torque due to the
reduction ratio. On the other hand when the motor mounts are on the plate 
the spacers only have to deal with half the prop torque or engine torque 
alone. Therefor spacer deflection due to prop torque is less and not more 
with the motor mounts on the plate rather than on the engine. 
Do you agree Tracy? 

I think you should offer this plate as standard equipment Tracy :-)

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org