Subject: A new interesting 100 HP VW based engine.
From: Paul
Date: 1/7/2001, 4:09 PM

Bill Freeman wrote:


I have overhauled MANY VWs over the years and have built a few aircraft
conversions.
I have heard of sodium filled valves many times, all were BS.  I have never
seen one and
seriously doubt they have ever existed.  The loss of valve stem strength
would absolutely
demand a much larger valve stem (stock VW stems are only 8mm - ~ 5/16") and
this is
a weak point of the engine design to begin with.  THE most common failure of
engines run
really hard is a dropped exhaust valve.  Using larger stems is possible, but
then the guides
are the issue.

Ultimately the non-counterweighted stock VW crank and relatively soft
magnesium alloy
case cannot support more RPM than stock (~ 4300 RPM max).  It pounds out the
case in relatively short order, I seen this many times.  Counterweighted forged
cranks exist and but very expensive.  The displacement is too small to get 100
HP at 4300 RPM esp with the relatively constricted head (port) design.

These are good 50 to 70 hp engines and will work reliably at the 3600 to
3800 RPM
cruise settings used by many, altho prop efficiency suffers some.  At least
the pictured
engine is driving off of the correct end of the engine.  Wonder if it has double
bearings on the spur gear to unload the crank?

If you need 50 to 70 hp and can stand the ~190 lb installed weight, go for
it.  Otherwise
buy an O-200 or O-235 for more HP (and weight), or a rotary  - for more HP
if your
airframe can deal with the added weight.

The only auto engines that have been designed and built to put out rated HP for
extended periods are the pre-1990s German cars since they had to be able to
cruise
on the autobahn at top speed for hours.  Nowdays the engines are protected by
the electronic systems, so they don't need to be as robust.  Even for the older
German auto engines, remember that they shouldn't be souped up, run as stock
since this is what they were designed to do.   Beware of car motors in general.

The rotary is a whole different class.

Bill

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org