Subject: two piece end housings single rotor
From: Paul
Date: 1/8/2001, 8:32 AM

Stone Tool wrote:

Paul:
    We've discussed this possibility before.....  I personally would rather
have a one piece plated housing.... I don't much like increasing the number
of gaskets, orings and seals in a system....  more failure points.

    The single rotor Mazda has dropped below the point of diminishing
returns in my opinion...... I was originally quite excited about the
possibility until I started doing some projections.    The weight is of
course considerably more than half that of a twin rotor to begin with as you
only eliminate the weight of the center housing, one rotor & housing and
some crankshaft.    You then add the weight of a full flywheel which I
believe is probably necessary due to the torsionals, and the necessary
redrive to that.
    A two rotor with all aluminum side housings or aluminum / iron running
direct drive would produce good power..... simply look at the torque charts
to see this..... there is very little reduction in torque until the RPM is
pretty low.    Properly designed peripheral ports intended to bring in
bottom end torque rather than increase horsepower could result in an engine
which could direct drive a prop 3000 or so RPM and pump out 60-70 HP.
    When you add the weight of a flywheel (not necessary on the direct
drive), and a redrive, counterweights, and irreducable weights the single
rotor simply does not stack up well against a reduced weight twin.  There
will be around 70-80 pounds more weight than half the weight of a driect
drive twin I suspect.

    The real problem in ultimate weight reduction on these engines single or
twin in my opinion is that you simply cannot get away from electric start
and associated electrical system...... short of doing really radical things
such as a ground based starting system.

    For my application I've about decided that Mazda power is pretty much
out.    I'd like to stay in the 150 lbs (FWF) and under range...... I don't
believe that is possible with any Mazda derivative that pumps out 50+ usable
horsepower.     It is achievable with a VW derived engine hence my interest
in that engine.

    By the way the Type 4 and VW Porche were the engines with sodium
valves........    The T4 is much superior to the Type 1, but also
considerably heavier.   Basic bare engine weight with no intake or exhaust
stuff, no prop hub or oil cooler, no mounts or ignition system on the T1  is
about 120 lbs.   I believe installed weights are running from 135-175 on
these depending on what is used and what is included in the FWF weight.
The T4 I believe is generally running around 170-200+.

    But we're here to talk about Mazda 13B conversions..... not VW engines
aren't we??

Starting with 190 lbs base engine weight:

A half 13B would probably weigh in at about 150 lbs for the base engine
figuring a reduction of about 40 lbs for center housing and one rotor and
housing, and some crankshaft.

Add to this 20 lbs for the flywheed which would be required and 30 lbs for a
PSRU, and you are already up to 200 lbs

An aluminum side housing 13B running direct drive would end up at about
150-160 starting weight

Now I don't know about you, but I have no problem deciding which option
makes the most sense.......   The direct drive 13B could probably pump out
just as much horsepower as a redriven 7.5B unless you choose to hop the
bejeasus out of it...... I'm talking about stock engines here.    Prop speed
would be a bit higher than desired, but that tradeoff is acceptable........
nothing is free.    The 2 rotor should be far more dependable....especially
when you remove the redrive from the equation.     I don't feel that the
7.5B has a useful niche.
    If you look at a total weight for a redriven 13B installed at about 280
lbs, and saw 40 lbs off that weight for a 7.5B  240 lbs.     The one pumping
out 140 HP, and the other only 70 HP.......   It really doesn't look so
good.   Even with a 10 lb lighter redrive and 10 lbs less cooling
system.....let's say 220 lbs  ( a bit optimistic), the weigh reduction as
compared to the  horsepower reduction doesn't exactly shine.     At best a
14% weight reduction as compared to a 50% power reduction............   Not
good numbers at all!!

    Aluminum housings allowing a 40 lbs reduction + 20 pounds of flywheel
removed + 35 lbs of redrive removed......   That's a 95 lb weight reduction
+ lightweight flywheel for starter..........  90 lbs below a stock 13B.
An aluminum direct drive 13B should come in just below 200 lbs FWF weight
and pump an honest 60 usable horses at a decent RPM.    That's a 32% weight
reduction in FWF weight for a 42% of the power..........   or something like
that...... a lot prettier picture I'd say, but without availability of
affordable aluminum pieces it's all smoke.

                                     H.W.


I don't agree Howard that a flywheel is all that necessary on a one rotor.

Paul Lamar

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org