Subject: Stalled decent rates in canard aircraft
From: Paul
Date: 1/14/2001, 11:07 AM

Stone Tool wrote:

I suspect that the reason for the slower than expected stalled decent rate
in a stalled canard aircraft is attributable to vortex lift as described by
Withold Kaspar.

http://members.home.net/twitt/wkasper.htm#kasperpage
Lots of good flying wing info on this site.   There used to be more on the
Kasparwing.....

    Kaspar's work with lift generating vortices which are produced at beyond
stalled angle of attack is some of the most interesting in aviation in
"recent" years.   These vortices will allow a vertical or near vertical
controlled decent at a rate similar to that described for the stalled
Velocity.     Proper design of the wing(s) and flight controls to harness
this characteristic and allow easy entry and egress from this condition
could be a real asset in some situations...... for example an engine out
over terra hostile where a steep decent into a very confined area could save
your bacon.    A 15-20 mph impact in flat attitude with the ground could be
very survivable with seat design built to provide spinal protection...... a
crush structure....   This could be infinitely preferable to flying into
terrain at normal flying speed moving forward.

                  H.W.


I think Kasper has it ass backwards. A vortex on top of the wing enhances
lift. Most modern fighter planes have sharp strakes to generate vortices
over the top of the wing enhancing the lift at high angles of attack.
Also dorsal fins in front of vertical stabilizers have the same effect
beyond that due strictly to tail volume calculated increases. 
Tail volume being defined as moment arm times side surface.

BTW Perkins and Hage Airplane Performance Stability and Control missed 
this point when they talk about dorsal fins on page 337. They know they are 
effective but they don't talk about why. 

IMHO the RV6 needs a dorsal fin because it has a very uncomfortable dutch 
roll on long cross countries. I know, I flew in one across the US.

Also small vortex generator are used to improve aileron and rudder 
effectiveness by the same mechanism. The core of a vortex is low pressure due
to the centrifugal forces on the air molecules. This sucks the vortex close
to what ever surface is in the vicinity. Sit next to the engine in a
737 on a rainy day next time you get a chance. Watch the vortex off the 
large vortex generator on the inside outer surface of the engine cowl 
stick to the wing as it goes up and over.

This is not to say large vortices are not generated over the wing by a Long Eze 
wing moving backwards in a spin. The wing trailing edge has the required sharpness.
This is quite plausible. The lift from the retreating wing may then balance 
the lift, about the CG, from the advancing wing keeping the Long Eze and 
or flying wing, BWB, etc., what have you in a flat spin helicopter or 
boomerang mode. Just a theory on my part.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org