Subject: Stalled decent rates in canard aircraft
From: Paul
Date: 1/14/2001, 5:06 PM


Drag at sea level is .0026 times MPH^2 times the area of
the wings. 60 MPH is 88 feet per second. 1200 FPM is only
20 feet per second or 13.6 MPH.
Dynamic pressure is only .482 pounds per square foot at 13.6 MPH.
200 square feet(?)is only 96 pounds of drag not 1500 pounds.
No way Jose.

Sounds like an urban myth to me.

Paul Lamar


There is a video clip of the velocity test that impacted the ocean,
as well as two NTSB reports available on line. The other incident
was a VariEz in Colorado I believe.

The thing with a canard main wing stall is there is still a forward
velocity component of lift. The canard just doesn't have enough
(any) authority to pull the nose down and reduce the alpha on
the main wing. Try your numbers again with 30-50 for V.

The max cl on a typical canard profile is 1.85 to 1.95 clean profile
and 2.35 to 2.65 with deflected flap/elevator.  The eppler 1230 is
the usual main wing profile on Ez's Cozy's and derivatives. Its
cl is 1.91 @ 13°.

Dave King

Well, was it spinning or not spinning in the video?

Sorry I don't buy those C sub L numbers Dave. Way too high. 
Most I can find in Von Doenhoff is about 1.6 for a similar 
thickness, moderate cambered airfoil.

Any kind of flaps are out of the question with most canards because the canard 
can not handle the main wing pitching moment. That is why the Beech Star Ship
had a movable canard (variable sweep).

Dynamic pressure is 6.5 pounds per square foot at 50 MPH. 200 square
feet is 1300 pounds. Perhaps. Run your ass into a brick wall at 50 MPH
and check your lower vertebrae. I would not want to do that at 13.5 MPH 1200 FPM
either for that matter. Perhaps we should supply parachuters with miniature 
scaled down blow up Long Eze's? :-) Just kidding.

Seriously, 50 MPH forward speed and 13.5 MPH downward is an angle of attack of
15 degrees. Sounds like the wing is flying to me.

So what you are saying (I think) is a canard will mush in at 1200 FPM and 50 MPH
and you will not be able to regain control. Well I guess that is possible
but is that safe? Why bother? Why not a conventional wing with a fowler flap
and enough control authority to get it out of a stall? 

Why not down force (up canard flap angle) on the canard? Heck you are still going 
50 MPH forward speed and 52 MPH relative speed.

Still does not compute.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org