Subject: Stalled decent rates in canard aircraft
From: Paul
Date: 1/14/2001, 5:29 PM


 Paul wrote:

 > This is not to say large vortices are not generated over the
wing by a Long Eze
 > wing moving backwards in a spin. The wing trailing edge has the
required sharpness.
 > This is quite plausible. The lift from the retreating wing may
then balance
 > the lift, about the CG, from the advancing wing keeping the Long Eze and
 > or flying wing, BWB, etc., what have you in a flat spin helicopter or
 > boomerang mode. Just a theory on my part.


 But I think the canards fall flat in normal attitude, with no spin.
 --
 Perry J. Mick
 Mick Duckt N7XR
 http://www.ductedfan.com


I can believe that if both front and rear wings are stalled and the
CG is exactly
in the wrong place but I find it hard to believe they come down at only
1200 fpm in that mode. What is the total wing area and gross weight?
You can then assume the wings are flat plates and have a drag coefficient
of one. You can then find the vertical speed that results in a drag equal
to the gross weight of the airplane.

Drag at sea level is .0026 times MPH^2 times the area of
the wings. 60 MPH is 88 feet per second. 1200 FPM is only
20 feet per second or 13.6 MPH.
Dynamic pressure is only .482 pounds per square foot at 13.6 MPH.
200 square feet(?)is only 96 pounds of drag not 1500 pounds.
No way Jose.

Sounds like an urban myth to me.

Paul Lamar

Hi all:

        This is from the Canard Pusher #68, July/91:

<BEGIN>
A Long-EZ was involved in an accident in Utah recently that resulted
in serious back injury to the pilot who was flying solo.  This pilot
was a relatively new private pilot with only a few hours in type.
While attempting to cut a roll of toilet paper, this pilot managed to
get the airplane too slow, with too much angle of attack and the
airplane apparently entered a "deep stall" condition.  The pilot did
not recover from the deep stall condition, and the aircraft descended
in a flat attitude (75 to 85 degrees AOA), striking the ground
slightly nose high with very little forward speed.  The pilot
suffered serious back injuries and the entire aircraft bottom and
landing gear were heavily damaged.
        There were a number of eye witnesses to this accident and our
investigation leads us to suspect that the aircraft was being flown
with a CG that was well aft of the published aft limit.  This
aircraft also was not equipped with vortilons.

THE FOLLOWING IS AN ANALYSIS OF THE UTAH ACCIDENT
        The Utah accident involved a deep stall, flat descent (angle
of attack of about 80 degrees).  The fact that the pilot survived and
that a slower-than-expected sink rate occurred (confirmed by video
tape evidence of the last 2.3 seconds of descent) presents somewhat
of a dilemma.  We are baffled as to why this can occur.  A similar
phenomena has been experienced during several deep stall accidents
with the Velocity aircraft.  All were survivable and one went into
water with the pilot experiencing no injury at all!  (See article in
July '91 Sport Aviation.)
        The Utah Long-EZ had a wing-loading of about 12.2 lbs./sq.
ft. and, considering all its area, including the wings, strakes, cowl
and fuselage, a "flat-plat loading" of about 9.2 lbs./sq. ft. (1150
lbs. divided by 125 sq. ft.).  A basic calculation of the predicted
rate-of-sink in a flat descent would use a flat-plate drag
coefficient of about 1.2 and would predict a sink of about 4820 ft.
per minute or 80 ft./sec.  This would definitely not be survivable.

        Using two different methods, we have calculated that the Utah
Long-EZ probably had a drag of about 2.8 times that predicted by
simple flat-plat theory, i.e. a co-efficient of about 3.3.  This
results in an energy at impact of only about 1/3 that which would
result from the "calculated prediction" sink of 4820 ft./min.  Here's
the two methods:

        1)  Analysis of the video tape shows a sink rate of about 48
ft./sec.  (2900 ft./min.).  This required measuring the size of the
airplane image and may be off as much as 30 percent.  The post-crash
video data show the rate of drift of dust from impact.  Comparing
this rate of drift of dust (wind was about 20 knots) to the rate of
sink of the airplane (on video) confirms the approximate 48 ft./sec.
estimate.

        2)  Assuming a 48 ft./sec. descent, the main landing gear
would absorb 18 ft./sec. before the fuselage strikes the dirt - this
is a relatively accurate calculation knowing the gear's stiffness and
strength.  Absorbing the remaining 30 ft./sec. over a total
deflection of approximately 6.7" (cushion, plus fuselage, plus dirt),
results in an average deceleration of about 25 G with a peak
deceleration of about 40 G.  Considering the support and attitude of
the pilots back, this is consistent with the injuries he sustained.
An 80 ft/sec descent would result in a fatal 150+ G impact of the
spine.
        Both these methods are very rough but (along with the deep
stall accident experience with the Velocity) they tell us that an
unusual phenomena is occurring.  It is likely that a large, trapped
vortex forms above the aircraft.  It's relatively easy to see how
this could increase the drag by 25 to 50 percent, but it makes no
logical sense that it could increase drag by a factor of 2.8 - this
would require the airplane to decelerate a column of air that is more
than 3 times the size of the airplane!  What is even more baffling is
the report (not confirmed by us) that the Velocity aircraft sinks at
less than 1500 ft/min (15 knots!).  If that were true, it would have
to have a "flat-plate" drag coefficient of about 12! !  (A totally
illogical result).  We suspect that the Velocity and Long-EZ have
similar drag coefficients and that the cushion of water landing
provided the difference in pilot injury.
        The Utah pilot had one thing going for him, he was sitting on
seat cushions fabricated from Tempa-Foam an excellent impact absorber.
        CONCLUSION:  What can we learn from this accident?  First of
all, don't just jump into someone's homebuilt airplane and go flying.
Insist on seeing a current weight and balance and discuss any
possible "quirks" the airplane may have with the owner.
  <END>

        Although this is terribly long - I couldn't figure where to
cut it - sorry! I'm
really interested in this subject that seems to defy logic...

Regards,
James

Anybody for a Long Eze parachute? :-)

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org