I agree with you both! For automotive use (and general marine use), the
factory method is fine. Engine durability exceeds expectations. I also
agree
that the deposits caused by the use of conventional motor oils are
Where the extra attention and complexity required by a separate
metering supply is warranted, it should be used. Perhaps aviation is such
an
application. IMHO, general automotive and marine uses do not require 2
stroke
oils, although
My .02.
Jon Lauter
Leon Promet wrote:
G'day John,
Been reading all the posts on 2 stroke oil with a lot of interest. I'm a
bit of a heretic on this issue, I have an insatiable curiosity and I would
therefore really like some scientific answers to issues raised by some
recent posts.
You say that 2 stroke oil injection is unnecessary in marine applications
and car applications and I would have to TOTALLY AGREE with you. From my
understanding, marine applications are usually medium to high
load/constant RPM applications, especially with the FORCED INDUCTION mods
you do to your engines (Yep, I've been to your website and I am mightily
impressed). People don't put engines like yours in boats for 5 knot
harbour cruises!! My experience with high performance road going forced
induction rotaries tallies exactly with your conclusions.
Tracey Crook also tells me that engines don't get anywhere near as hard a
time in aircraft as they do in cars. He told me in a post on the FlyRotary
forum that, and I quote: "Our use is typically "low stress" compared to
the racing environment". (and he ought to know; I'm reliably told he's got
more hours up than anybody else).
So Mate, I'm getting really totally and utterly confused (and I bet a lot
of others out there are as well!). Some questions for you.
What deposits are, to quote you "caused by the use of conventional motor
oils"?
>From whence do they come?
Under what circumstances do they form?
How could "an improvement in internal cleanliness could likely be gained"
by the use of a two stoke oil rather than more frequent engine oil & filter
changes?
Is this extra "cleanliness" necessary, and is it beneficial to the engine's
power output and/or durability??
If a good quality modern synthetic engine oil like Mobil 1, Castrol,
AmsOil or Neo is used, and is changed regularly along with the oil filter,
how can these be, to quote you "detrimental to the ultimate potential
durability and performance of the engine"?
Maybe there is somebody out there can set me straight on these issues as
well:
Does anybody out there have any idea of the difference between the
lubrication requirements of a Wankel engine and a 2 stroke engine.
Has anybody got any idea why oil injection/mixing in the fuel is necessary
on a 2 stroke?
Does anybody have any idea what's the difference between proper modern
synthetic engine oil and a good quality synthetic 2 stroke oil?
While I'm here, Paul made the most delicious statement;
" Burns the crap out of the crankcase."
So Paul, ... how does engine oil (or 2 stroke oil for that matter) burning
in the combustion chambers do the above?
One of Paul's other statements was:
"Every engine I ever looked into was carboned up so bad you could barely
scrape it off with a chisel. Several had stuck apex seals."
Does that mean that, if I continue to use the standard Mazda factory oil
injection system, I can expect my road car engines to eventually clog up
and apex seals to stick?
So Paul, how do you know that the carbon deposits were formed from the
INJECTED oil anyway??
Very Sincerely,
Leon Promet
There are a lot of additives such as phosphorus and zinc in motor oil that
are entirely unnecessary in oil used to lubricate and cool apex seals.
These additives are for such things as high pressure line to
line contact on camshafts and valve lifters.
These additives are part of the source of deposits on the rotors
and can cause the apex seals to stick in the slots. Also see my
previous comments on Archie post. Nobody is forcing anybody to mix
two cycle oil with the fuel.
BTW we went over this extensively at least a year ago and mixing two cycle
oil with rotary racing car fuel has been practiced for decades. I also
don't agree with Tracy on the duty cycle of racing cars being more severe
than aircraft use. Tracy lives in flat Florida where it is almost never necessary
to climb at full power for 45 minutes or so. Racing car use is rarely above
80% average duty cycle for road racing and races are 24 hours at most.
And those are rare. True, higher RPM's are reached but only for fractions
of a second. A rotary racing car engine with more than about
300 hours on it is rare indeed and that includes Star Mazda spec racing cars.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org