Here are my thoughts on the matter, largely unsubstantiated by any direct
comparisons!
Conventional motor oils (including synthetics) are designed to operate in the
crankcase of a piston engine. The basestock is formulated to provide basic
hyrdrodynamic lubrication and to keep the additives in suspension. In a
crankcase, it is desired to have the oil be very non-volatile to minimize
consumption. Additives are used for anti-wear (these are typically metallic
salts based on zinc), detergents (based on calcium and magnesium), overbase
additives to neutralize acidic contaminants, dispersants to keep wear
particles in suspension so the filter can get them, etc. The metallic
additives will produce ash deposits in any engine it they can get to surfaces
that are very hot (like the combustion pocket in a rotor or a piston crown).
Metallic ash deposits are very hard and are the light colored deposits that
are on a spark plug in a high oil useage engine. The rest of the oil (mostly
the basestock) can leave carbonaceous deposits if the temperatures are hot
enough to oxidize the lube but not hot enough to fully burn all the
constituents cleanly. In some respects, a synthetic oil could concievably be
worse in that the oil is less volatile -- it will stay in the combustion
chamber longer and may cook into a heavier deposit.
Two stroke oils, on the other hand, are designed to go into a hot combustion
environment, provide lubrication for a period of time, and then disappear
cleanly. Their volatiltiy is balanced to provide long enough lubrication
under a constant replenishment scheme.
My earlier post reflected the nature of compromises in any engineered system,
For my marine customers, and for most automotive customers, the possible
improvement in engine durability and performance from a separate two stroke
oiling system is not worth the extra expense and effort. Also, again, I have
no direct experience with two stroke oils in rotary engines, but from all I
have read it would certainly seem that the oils are more suited to the rotary
combustion environment and should be expected to keep the internals of the
engine cleaner. I do know that engine deposits can cause broken and stuck
seals. I would absolutely NOT recommend using two stroke oils in the rotary
crankcase.
Jon Lauter
Rotary Power Marine Corporation
Thanks Jon. Excellent post on the subject.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org