Ken Powell wrote:
Leon,
I know that I do not have the experience with rotary engines that you
have; however, I have disassembled 4 13b's. All came from cars with
less than 125,000 miles and NO body damage. These cars were in the
junk yard because the engines were DEAD. Upon disassembly, 3 of
these engines had apex seals that were obviously stuck - I can not
say for certain that rust was not involved but if so, I could not see
it. Carbon appeared to be the cause. The forth engine had broken an
apex seal but was in pretty good shape otherwise. I might add that
what little oil left in the pan (the yard drains all liquids) was
filthy. Without a doubt, filty mineral oil will ruin an oil injected
rotary engine. I maitain that for aircraft use a good grade of
marine 2 stroke oil should be mixed with the gas. It can't hurt and
will almost certainly help. Besides, there is less to go wrong - no
oil pump or oil lines.
Ken Powell
Leon Promet wrote:
Hi Ken,
I think we will have to draw a line and agree to disagee here. I've asked
a lot of questions, and got a variety of opinions. Now I'll reveal mine.
Please understand that I am not against mixing 2 stroke oil in the fuel per
se. That's not the issue. I've done it regularly on race cars for 25 years,
and it works just fine. But I have had two engine failures because somebody
fuelled my race car when I was not present and forgot to put the 2-stroke
oil in the fuel. Which brings me to my main reason for being antagonistic
to the practice of removing the metering pump. It has nothing to do with
longevity of the engine. It has to do with personal bodily and financial
security.
My main reason for being dead against disconnecting the factory oil
metering pump, apart from the inconvenience and mess of mixing two stroke
into the fuel, getting the ratio correct, and making sure it is properly
distributed etc is that in an aircrraft application, you only have to
forget to put the two-stroke in the sucker once and you are DEAD!! No
thanks, I'll stick with the standard Factory engine oil metering
arrangement which is perfectly satisfactory if the normal service routines
are followed.
What I am also dead against is disconnecting the oil metering pump
willy-nilly because it is usually disconnected for entirely the wrong
reason(s), usually because people think their motors will last longer,
using the hoary old chestnut of carbon and ash build-up on rotors and
stuck seals (just like you and others have) without any real understanding
why and how the carbon/ash built up got there.
As for the carbon/ash build up on the rotors, So what? Where did the
'carbon' build-up come from anyway Ken? Did it come from burning the
injected oil or did it come from burning oil that bypassed the oil control
rings (caused by hardened "O" rings, worn oil control rings and worn side
faces?) How old were these motors, how many miles on them, and what sort
of driving history did they have?
Obviously the service history was abysmal as evidenced by the filthy oil!!
Betcha they were all city cars with low miles and lots of short trips
where they never got to proper operating temp, and never got to design RPM
on a regular basis (read 7,000 RPM, otherwise why buy a rotary??), and
probably using K-Mart special oil!!!! Same goes for stuck seals. Same
cause. You said yourself that the engine oil was filthy!
If you are worried about carbon build-up and seal lubrication, then please
understand that I'm not against upper cylinder lubricant additives in the
fuel either, as it assists in keeping the combustion chambers and seals in
tip-top condition. I will readily agree with and heartily recommend that
a LITTLE (500:1) upper cylinder lubricant once every few tanksfuls is a
good thing in a rotary, as it is in any motor. But too much in a
turbocharged engine can cause premature detonation by lowering the octane
rating. 2 Stroke oil in a turbocharged engine is not at all good in this
respect. If the engine oil is injected, particularly as in the late model
engines directly into the housings, lubricant is put where it is most
needed, on the apex seal-trochoid interface, not in the inlet charge
where most of it is wasted and does awful things to the octane rating. (Not
an issue in NA engines).
Having rebuilt thousands of these engines, and known the full history of a
lot of the cars, I can say categorically that rotary engines will run in
excess of 200,000 miles if serviced properly, with oil and filter changed
at regular intervals (Max 10,000 km or every 6 months). Any good quality
oil is OK, but for many years, I have recommended Mobil 1 (no ash and no
Zinc by the way!) if people were prepared to pay the extra. All this
nonsense about not using synthetic oil in Rotaries is absolute balderdash
and malarky. Why do I say that? Because I've seen it with my own eyes on
MANY occasions, and demonstrated it over a period of 15 years and hundreds
of motors running on Mobil 1, AmsOil, Neo etc.
Anyway, it is getting all too tedious. I've put in my several quids
worth. People will believe what they want to believe no matter what the
empirical evidence , and no matter what logical reasons are proffered. I
have persevered so far because I just don't want to read some day that
someone had an engine failure and got killed or seriously injured because
he/she forgot to put 2 stroke in the fuel. All the peanut gallery will
then crow, "See, I told you them rotaries were no good!!".
I think we might as well leave it there. Sorry to have wasted everybody's
time. Just make sure you always remember to put the 2 stroke in the fuel
EVERY time OK??!!
Sincerely,
Leon Promet
Well Leon I think you exaggerate just slightly :-) Is that one engine a day
overhauled for the last six years or one engine every two days overhauled
for the last twelve years? :-) That's a lot of rotor cleaning. What is your
secret for cleaning rotors?
George Graham forgot to mix two cycle oil in the gas in his 13B powered canard
on a trip from Memphis Tennessee to Buffalo NY a couple of years ago and he
and his wife are still alive. Last time I checked the engine was still running
fine but second gear in the RX7 gear box driving the prop was stripped.
Besides all that cleaning the rotors takes a couple of days. Actual rebuilding
the engine only a few hours.
A third issue is almost every ten year old or older Mazda engine I have looked
at has highly brittle aged nylon lines feeding oil to the injectors. In many
cases these lines are cracked and leaking.
I also have a picture around here of a rotor housing that shows a wear
pattern indicative of indicate oil spreading out of the oil injector
port. I'll dig it up when I come back from the doctors office.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org