Leon Promet wrote:
Hi Tracey,
Maaaaaaaaaaaaaate, seriously, what was my point? Wasn't I warning
people
about the dangers of WRONG MIXTURES and timing in TURBOCHARGED
applications.
Sure mate, you can get away with really silly timing advance and super
lean mixtures and ridiculously high EGT at cruise in a naturally
aspirated
motor, and sure the engine is not working hard cruising at 10,000 ft.
Agreed! No contest ... But in a turbo engine, under boost, at ground
level on takeoff, it's a WHOLE different ball game.
So if, as you say, and I quote:
" This only happens with engine operation near the outer limits of BMEP
or
RPM. This just never occures in the real world of aircraft operations.
To
my knowledge, there is not a single example of an OPERATIONAL rotary
powered airplane that is even mildly turbocharged".
are you are telling me that nobody is actually running a turbocharged
rotary engine in an aircraft yet, and ADDITIONALLY, if they are, never
at
or close to max BMEP, and therefore NOBODY really has experience in
these
matters of turbo engines at takeoff?
The next thing I suppose you are going to tell me is that in any case,
you
are not working the ring off an engine at takeoff/climbout, and
therefore
my racing experiences are invalid?
OK, tell me Tracey, what's the difference between loading a 13B turbo
up
on a 4,500 ~ 5,000 RPM stall torque converter (autos don't "miss shifts"
}:>), maaaaaaaaate), and then running a quarter mile drag in a car
weighing say 1000 Kg (10 ~ 14 sec depending on boost level) and doing a
similar thing in a 13B turbo powered aircraft weighing about the same
mass?
Hmmmmm ... ? Isn't an aircraft on full noise for a lot longer at WOT
than
my drag car, yet experiencing the same load?
If a drag race engine detonates and disintegrates, (and I've had quite a
few of them do that before the advent of 3D digital EFI engine
management
systems), the driver simply knocks the gearbox into neutral, utters a
few
expletives and coasts to a stop, whistles up the pit crew, tows it
back
to the pits, swaps the spare engine and is back on the track within an
hour or so. No Wurries Mate!
Not really an option in an aircraft on a short strip when you are well
beyond V1 and just rotated and/or just airborne, or even worse, just
about to clear the tree-line at the end of the runway. As the
Mitsubishi
advert says "Please Consider!"
Sincerely,
Leon Promet
Tracy Crook wrote:
Not that there is anything basically wrong with trying it but yes, I am
saying that there is no one (to my knowledge) who has an *operational*
aircraft with a turbocharged rotary. A few hours of flight before ditching
the project does not qualify as operational (IMHO). You do hear a LOT of
talk but that's all it usually is. If there are working turbo installations
out there, I'd love to hear about them. There are many projects *on the
ground* with turbos. Readers of this newsgroup (and it's a really great
thing, thanks Paul) know that I quickly get bored with academic discussions
of non-operational stuff. Nothing wrong with it, it's just not my thing.
There is nothing wrong with the technical points you made Leon. I'm just
saying that they are not a concern for 90+ percent of people interested in
flying the Mazda rotary. This newsgroup is a valuable tool because of the
input from people like yourself. The only problem is that many builders
have no idea what which discussions apply to their project, so they take
every word as gospel. I have lost count of the number of calls I've had
from people who decided to switch engines or drop their project completely
because they felt like they could never cope with extream difficulties
encountered with the rotary. Nothing could be further from the truth, there
are fewer problems with the rotary than on any piston engine.
Having said all this, I got a call this morning from Greg Richter who just
flew his turbo 13B for the first time. He used up to 40" manifold pressure
on takeoff and had no cooling problems during the two circuits of the
pattern. Greg's 13B is equipped with a turbo EC2 engine controller. He
made the first flight on his own planetary drive (with a 3 planet carrier!)
but plans to install my RD-1B six planet drive when its available. (parts
for the RD-1B are on order now) Greg's plane has not met the requirements
to be called "operational" yet but I think he will get there.
Tracy Crook
rws@altavista.net
www.rotaryaviation.com
Always nice to hear about yet another rotary powered airplane flying
turbo or no turbo. Thanks Tracy
Hopefully we will hear from CJ Smale soon on his turbo Deviant. Hint hint CJ :-)
Does look like it has flown.
BTW For Sale one RD-1 with four pinion planet carrier :-)
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org