Subject: Independent Oil Filter study
From: Paul
Date: 1/23/2001, 6:11 PM


I use the HP1 too and it is a good filter.  This is not the same as saying
that all Fram filters are good (I don't know if they are or not).  The HP1 &
HP2 are not typical automotive filters.  They were intended to be
transmission filters capable of handling higher pressures than most auto
filters.  You probably noticed that they are heavier (wall thickness is
higher) and I'm SURE you noticed that they cost about 3 - 4 times as much
:-)

Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com

  I was very concerned about Fram filters quality ( or lack)
after reading this web site.  I tore down one each from
my two Hondas, my Blazer and DID NOT find the interior
quality, fit, finish, etc as claimed in the site.  They are
not works of art, but they look about the same as one
sample of the "high quality" filter (I forget the brand)
recommended on the site which I opened up.  One sample
does not make a "study", but I was satisfied that the site
was wrong.  One Honda has 230K, no problems with
99% Fram filters.  How bad can they be?

Yes, the HP1 is a racing filter and thicker walls to withstand
higher pressures, which I get with a cold start on my Lyc.
Quality looks as good as the inside of a Champion airplane
filter, altho I'm no expert on oil filters.

 Take the time to cut a few filters open, DECIDE FOR
YOURSELF.  I'm not selling Fram filters, and only used
them because they had been recommended 30 yrs ago
by a racer friend.  Things can change a LOT in tha time.  So,
I checked several.  I am currently using Castrol brand filters
(newly hit the local auto parts stores) and will tear down
each to see  how they look inside.  Chose those because I
have had excellent service from Castrol oil for about 30 yrs.

Anybody with a computer can become an expert in
anything in the internet.  DON'T blindly believe
ANYTHING that might cost you money or your
life without checking to see if it fits with whatever
you can check out with other experts or by personal
research (test or library).   INCLUDING what I say !
I can make mistakes, too, just like anybody else, and
will appreciate anyone pointing out my errors.  Might
have to agree to disagree sometimes . . .   ;-)

Bill

Make mistakes. Woh me? :-)

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org