David Doshay wrote:
Well, for what it is worth, here is the answer from AVEMCO:
Date: Thu, 25 Jan 2001 09:18:44 -0500
From: "Adams, Mike" <madams@ave.com>
Subject: Velocity Aircraft
David,
Becky passed your e-mail along to me for response. Please see my
answers in blue.
note: they did not come through in blue, so I offset them with a gap and my
notation that the answer is from AVEMCO.
If you have any other questions please do not hesitate to
contact us.
Regards,
Mike Adams
Vice President Underwriting
madams@ave.com
David:
-----Original Message-----
From: David Doshay
Sent: Wednesday, January 24, 2001 5:06 PM
To: Wilson, Rebecca
Subject:
Ms. Wilson,
It was nice speaking with you on the phone about my concerns
regarding the insurability of my Velocity aircraft and how that affects my
plans to install an auto conversion into the aircraft. As per that
conversation, below are my two additional questions for you to forward to
the proper person or committee at AVEMCO.
I look forward to the Company's reply.
1) Does the "no auto conversions" rule apply only to Velocity
aircraft, or are other specific kinds of homebuilt or kit planes insurable
by AVEMCO with auto conversions?
In particular, I have read email from someone with an RV
aircraft and the same kind of a conversion I am considering who has coverage
>from AVEMCO. Is there something different about that brand of kit which
makes it different from a Velocity, or was that individual "grandfathered"
because they got their insurance prior to the "no auto conversion" rule?
AVEMCO:
David, our loss history with auto engines in aircraft has not been
particulariliy good. There are some airframe and auto engine combinations
that we do provide some insurance on, at this time the Velocity aircraft is
not one of them.
David:
and
2) Given that many people will not fly without insurance, how
does the experimental aircraft community bring data to the insurers that a
particular auto conversion might be safe enough for them to insure? In
particular, many people with the resources to carefully develop and test a
conversion's installation in an aircraft are the same people who do not dare
fly without insurance, while people with "less to lose" might be willing to
put a project together at lower expense, and with less testing, and fly it
without insurance. Given that many people interested in homebuilt aviation
would like to contribute to advancing the state of the art beyond the older
technology which is the basis of the certificated aircraft engines, how can
the development and testing take place without the availability of
insurance? To offer up a suggestion, would it be possible to obtain
insurance which only covers liability and which does not include airframe
coverage? After all, if we built it, we can repair it and likely would have
no problem accepting that risk.
AVEMCO:
You are bringing up a variety of questions
here ranging from research & developement issues to amature built aircraft
>from proven plans/kits. Our desire in providing insurance for homebuilt
aircraft and in working with the EAA is to provide some measure of insurance
to the large majority of homebuilders. Any time a new product/model or
modification is introduced the insurance industry will tend towards the
conservative when offering (if at all) insurance. As the new model builds a
record, hopefully a good one towards realiability and safety, the insurance
industry will adjust its underwriting of the item. Some aircaft after they
were introduced ceased flying after a short traumatic history and the
insurance industry never did, or would, offer insurance for it, or if there
was initially insurance available it was soon withdrawn. Often times
insurance for an item only becomes available after the product has been in
operation for a number of years (successfully) and there are a sufficent
number of the items operating to make it feasible for the insurance industry
to measure the risk and set a premium to cover the anticipated losses. Most
of the initial developement and testing that has gone on has either been
done without insurance or the insurance may have been purchased via a
surplus lines broker (a Lloyds of London type policy). Is there a risk in
that? Most definitly. Is there risk in having to pay an insurance premium
that may bankrupt you? Yes.
If insurance is not available for your program (developeing an auto
engine for an aircraft that has not been proven with an auto engine yet),
there are several things you can do to help limit your risk such as, do your
test flying out of an airport that is not surrounded by buildings, test fly
in an area that if you go down the property damage claims are likely to be
small. Other than secrecy there is a good reason that Burt's business is
out in the Mojove. Don't let anyone else in your aircraft, an exception
would be your immediate family members as they often are limited in the
suits they could bring against you. Have your engine test stand simulate
all possible flight conditions, such as pressure changes with altitude,
induction iceing, fuel control, etc. Have another person that is an expert
in the modification that you are doing check your work.
You might check back to us when you get closer to having your
aircraft signed off for flight tests as we are continually re-evaluating how
we are, or, are not insuring certain aircraft & engines.
You might also want to work closely with the Velocity company on
your project.
Regads - Mike Adams
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org